So, you open your envelope and set your device to measure if the sock is 0.2 red and 0.8 soft (so, either blue or soft), and you get True. If the person who got the other sock set their device to 0.8 red and 0.2 soft, the classical probability that they get True would be 0.5 I believe.
But if you perform this experiment with quantum entangled properties, you would see a greater value. Further, Bell has shown that one of 3 things must hold for quantum socks:
- either they are neither blue/red nor coarse/fluffy until the measurement; after the measurement, your sock gets some value, and the other sock implicitly gets the opposite value, but there is no real "state change" since they didn't have any state to begin with (we reject realism)
- they "tell" each other instantly in what state they were found (we reject locality)
- the fact that you were always going to receive the red sock also caused you to choose 0.2 red and 0.8 soft, so what may look like a coincidence is in fact pre-determined (superdeterminism)
Search for Wigner's friend. Relational quantum mechanics is the only logical and consistent epistemology for what all this means.
Effectively, nothing ever changes, just extra information allows for simplification of observables backed by large expressions.
The universe is inherently lazy, and it's like LISP. PG come at me!
But objective collapse due to anyone's consciousness does not solve anything - my observation of this particle still causes infinite speed effects on your particle, so the universe is anyway non-local.
There is a correlation between us, still. So it isn't like our wavefunctions are going to be radically different. We both are entangled since the Big Bang and even after that many times over as shared information exchanges between us.
In general, I believe the most obvious interpretation of consciousness is simply as a computational process, so looking at consciousness as a key to QM is incompatible with my beliefs.
Furthermore, given the classical-ness of the world we see everyday, I have huge problems believing theories like MWI or these consciousness-based ones that claim the world is entirely quantum everywhere and it's just some kind of accident that it seems so classical to us (contrast to relativity which has a very satisfying answer for why we don't notice the difference from classical mechanics).
The universe is indifferent to your persuasions. The double slit experiment has been successfully performed on large molecules of 810 atoms. Quantum mechanics is fundamentally about knowledge and information after interactions. You seem to be a physics guy but something tells me you aren't aware that every single interaction causes entanglement. Entanglement is simply a constraint on interaction products, given the input particles. It is just easier to see its effects on small objects since they are less likely to be perturbed.
I think we just don't know enough yet to choose any one interpretation. I hope that at some point we'll find a way to address the measurement problem - either finding that the classical world also behaves quantically or that there is some clear limit between them or that the quantum world behaves classically (least likely).
But until then, we're all just guessing.
Edit: 810 atoms is great, just ~6.023*10^21 more to go and we'll have something that is truly in our range of advertising.
Eraser experiments have already shown that collapse either doesn't actually happen or is reversible. It appears that all observables are just lazily evaluated nested expressions. Collapse/decoherence is just the phenomena of simplification of expressions. The expressions don't change. In the quantum eraser experiment, the erasure causes the expression to no longer be simplifiable.
This would assume that somehow the atoms in our brain work differently than the atoms anywhere else. There is nothing special about consciousness.
Honestly, the rest of your post is a bunch of mumbo jumbo, it’s difficult to see what you are trying to say.
You assume wrongly. The implication is that all wavefunctions have a corresponding consciousness. Since the universe is a nested set of wavefunctions, it's essentially all consciousness.
There is nothing special about consciousness, it's the unified field, it's all there actually is.
Honestly, the rigidity of your thinking holds you back from seeing any deeper truth.
Since humans have finite lifespans, we all develop some heuristics (probably heavily biased ones) to serve as filters for what is efficient to consider.
As such, one of my (again, heavily biased) filters are any such claims that meditation could have an outsized impact on the level of deviance/crime in the Washington DC.
" We present the published results of a National Demonstration Project-in which 4,000 advanced meditators markedly reduced violent crime in Washington, DC."
I simply don't have time to consider this as my personal biases are telling me to ignore it and that it is bad science.
Furthermore, the researcher here very frequently makes use of highly theoretical and even unproven concepts such as string theory and a particular variant of the multiple universes idea which has also not been proven. Both are presented misleadingly as concrete fact rather than assumptions made. I dislike being misled and distrust the researcher moreso because of that.
I assume your biases are quite different from mine. I assume some level of experimentation with hallucinogenic drugs may be involved? No judgement - I've just seen lots of similar appeals to philosophical interpretations of physics from other LSD users I know.
> You assume wrongly. The implication is that all wavefunctions have a corresponding consciousness. Since the universe is a nested set of wavefunctions, it's essentially all consciousness.
First, a wavefunction is a way of making sense of (some of) the concepts of quantum mechanics. It has a specific meaning, and scientists to this day argue about whether it is necessary or actually a thing.
When it is used, it is a scalar field that is used to describe the probability of some experimental result, i.e. a mathematical tool. It has no link whatsoever with consciousness, which is the result of electric signals going up and down a group of neurons bunched together.
You sound like you want to redefine “consciousness” as “existence”. In that case there is some tautological beauty in what you say, but it is not as enlightening as you seem to think it is.
> There is nothing special about consciousness, it's the unified field, it's all there actually is.
What the hell does that even mean? You use scientific-sounding words without seeming to grasp their meaning.
I mean, surrealism is fun, and metaphysics can be interesting, but don’t confuse them with a deep understanding of physical truths.
> https://youtu.be/LPhgDfT4Zpc
I need to point out that you are citing a crackpot and that there was absolutely nothing scientific in what I have seen in this video. But yeah, it probably is my mental rigidity talking.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_wavefunction
> Since the universal validity of the state function description is asserted, one can regard the state functions themselves as the fundamental entities, and one can even consider the state function of the entire universe. In this sense this theory can be called the theory of the "universal wave function," since all of physics is presumed to follow from this function alone.[7]
You appeal to a trivially naive interpretation of what the wavefunction represents, yet claim that I or Hagelin are the crackpots. Don't you know that all modern science requires unobservables? Yet you want to constrain the wavefunction to being a mathematical tool for measurement only because that was its intended purpose and conceptual creation. Narrow mindset.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unobservable
> You use scientific-sounding words without seeming to grasp their meaning.
You think you understand quantum physics when no one does. Furthermore, you don't even understand wavefunctions except by their textbook definition...
The map is not the territory. A ball is a ball and its motion is its motion, while Newton's equations of motion for that ball are something else.
While it is possible that the MWI is right and the state of the entire universe could be described by a single, universal wavefunction, that wouldn't mean that the universe is that wavefunction, anymore than Maxwell's equations are the electromagnetic field.
Now, there is an interesting question that indeed no one knows the answer to for now: is the wavefunction a direct description of a physical object, or is it just a statistical tool for predicting possible positions of the real objects (waves and particles existing in some duality)?
Also, you shouldn't forget that none of the existing interpretations of QM actually solve the measurement problem, not even MWI. Here is Sabine Hossenfelder's explanation of this [0]:
> In the many worlds interpretation, if you set up a detector for a measurement, then the detector will also split into several universes. Therefore, if you just ask “what will the detector measure”, then the answer is “The detector will measure anything that’s possible with probability 1.”
> This, of course, is not what we observe. We observe only one measurement outcome. The many worlds people explain this as follows. Of course you are not supposed to calculate the probability for each branch of the detector. Because when we say detector, we don’t mean all detector branches together. You should only evaluate the probability relative to the detector in one specific branch at a time.
> That sounds reasonable. Indeed, it is reasonable. It is just as reasonable as the measurement postulate. In fact, it is logically entirely equivalent to the measurement postulate. The measurement postulate says: Update probability at measurement to 100%. The detector definition in many worlds says: The “Detector” is by definition only the thing in one branch. Now evaluate probabilities relative to this, which gives you 100% in each branch. Same thing.
> And because it’s the same thing you already know that you cannot derive this detector definition from the Schrödinger equation. It’s not possible. What the many worlds people are now trying instead is to derive this postulate from rational choice theory. But of course that brings back in macroscopic terms, like actors who make decisions and so on. In other words, this reference to knowledge is equally in conflict with reductionism as is the Copenhagen interpretation.
[0] http://backreaction.blogspot.com/2019/09/the-trouble-with-ma...
The wavefunction of the universe is the state of it, and all conscious observers _ever_ do, is measure states. Interaction is all there is, just relationships. The state is isomorphic to the reality. The only difference is the reality has some process running on it, to advance the arrow of time.
This is not confusing the map for the territory. Every physicist you ask will tell you that a particle is the matrix it is represented by. Now, we may not have those matrixes fully complete or accurate, but the backing of reality IS information. And no, information and numbers do not have to have a reality onto themselves - they are just the medium of comparison, otherwise any description is impossible. All descriptions that humans use are metaphors based on past experience.
That just begs the question of what consciousness actually is. You can define consciousness as being the wave function, but then you still have to actually check if what 'consciousness' colloquially means has any resemblance to that.
For example, when you tell me something is conscious, I expect that I can teach that thing certain things, like how to sing or how to fetch. Since a photon has a wavefunction, by your definition I would expect to be able to teach a photon to do things.
Similarly, I expect conscious things to be able to interact with the world and have feelings about it. Do you beleive a photon admires an electron more than a proton, or anything similar?
Until you can show any experiments where anything that is known to be described by a wavefunction is shown to have all of the properties we associate with the word 'consciousness' in everyday usage, your assertion that all wavefunctions have a corresponding 'consciousness' doesn't really mean anything. I could just as easily say that all wavefunctions have an associated music, and that music is all there actually is. It's a definition, so it's not wrong, but it's not illuminating.
The possible futures for a photon, given the laws of physics, are much simpler than for you or I. Its wavefunction is known. The usual (classical) Maxwell field is the quantum wave function for a single photon.
> Similarly, I expect conscious things to be able to interact with the world and have feelings about it. Do you beleive a photon admires an electron more than a proton, or anything similar?
You are confusing consciousness with reactiveness. Deterministic rules can cause reactions. Your refrigerator for example, reacts to temperature changes. It however, is not exercising free will or any kind of quantum randomness to do so.
> Until you can show any experiments where anything that is known to be described by a wavefunction is shown to have all of the properties we associate with the word 'consciousness' in everyday usage, your assertion that all wavefunctions have a corresponding 'consciousness' doesn't really mean anything. I could just as easily say that all wavefunctions have an associated music, and that music is all there actually is. It's a definition, so it's not wrong, but it's not illuminating.
There is no rule-based construct for random number generation except for PRNG[1]. It follows that, if true randomness is exhibited by the universe, one that is not generated by rules, then it must be the leftover ingredient. Consciousness is the only leftover ingredient. Everything else we know about physics is deterministic and rule-based. Now, you know very well, things like this are likely not able to be proven given the hard consciousness problem and the other proximal issues. So I'm making an argument. Some things in life are arguments, not proofs. Like political views. Get used to it instead of being cliche and resorting to Newton's Flaming Laser Sword.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pseudorandom_number_generator
Now, you could say that consciousness is a quantity that humans possess a lot of, while photons possess a tiny little amount of, like the Integrated Information Theory people claim. But there is no proof (or even indication, in my opinion) that the IIT 'consciousness' actually captures what we mean by human consciousness.
> It follows that, if true randomness is exhibited by the universe, one that is not generated by rules, then it must be the leftover ingredient. Consciousness is the only leftover ingredient. Everything else we know about physics is deterministic and rule-based.
Randomness is not necessarily a part of QM. For example, in MWI, there is no randomness in the universe - it is perfectly deterministic, as every state of the wave function is realized. In pilot-wave theory, the only randomness is classical - errors in knowing the initial state with absolute precision.
Even if CI or other fundamental randomness interpretations of QM are correct, there is no obvious connection between consciousness and randomness. There are other unknowns in the universe - you could just as easily say that dark matter is consciousness or dark matter is the source of randomness, or dark energy etc.
And only since you briefly mentioned it, free will (as in conscious choice affecting the next state of the universe) is incompatible with QM, as QM is a linear theory, where the next state is uniquely determined by the previous state, especially in MWI.
Rules are not a source of real randomness and there is a consensus among physicists that quantum randomness is actually true randomness. Even if you put the source of randomness into some other thing like dark matter, you cannot explain its construct..because all you have is rules. You must forfeit and concede to nature a black box RNG library. This is clearly ludicrous. The more obvious and consistent view is that conscious beings (that feel they have willful decisions) are the manifestation of nature's RNG for quantum mechanics
IIT is an entirely different beast related to self attention, a different kind of definition for consciousness, that has little to do with will. Unrelated...
QM is unitary, but it is one to many. It's a giant branching rooted tree. This is irrelevant, it is not deterministic like general relativity.
Please step back in the element. These refutations are becoming exhausting.
In CI there is indeed true randomness, since only one 'branch' of the wavefunction is actually happening.
Say you are going to flip a quantum coin. Before you flip it, given MWI, you know that there will be two copies of you, each experiencing one of the outcomes. After you flip it, one copy sees tails, the other heads. Each copy is perfectly identical except for the new observation. Each may ask itself 'what were the chances that I am seeing heads/tails?', and with MWI in mind, they should answer 1: the chance that the copy-that-sees-heads sees heads is 1, and same for copy-who-sees-tails seeing tails, since there is no other way to identify them as separate entities.
This also corresponds to the mathematics of QM: if you want to give proper predictions, you need to 'update' the wavefunciton to have value 1 for the observed outcome and value 0 for any other outcome. Doing that for 'your branch' is precisely how MWI works.
Taking your example of the socks, with their varying and inverse properties, why do we need "spooky action at a distance" to describe the fact that one can test the properties of their local sock and therefore know the properties of the distant, entangled sock? If we now that the total value of each property will equal 1 (as in your case) then measuring the local sock will tell us the values of the distant sock.
I am not sure what I am missing, only that I am missing something here.
Fundamentally the answer is that you can't break a Bell inequality with the socks, but you can with some entangled particles.
The socks analogy kinda fails to capture the interesting stuff here, and I'm not sure if any classical analogy really works, but I'm gonna try to summarise the setup.
You have two boxes (imagine they're in different rooms, being operated by different people), call them A and B. Each Box allows you to input a single bit, we'll call A's bit x and B's bit y. Each box outputs a single bit in response to the bit you give it, call the bit output by A a, and the bit output by B b. You can then form a probability distribution
P(a,b | x, y)
The joint probability distribution of a and b conditioned on the inputs x and y. Quantum mechanics predicts a particular form for this distribution, and in particular it does not depend where the boxes are, and when (in which order) the bits are input. Based on special relativity therefore we would expect that the distribution of a conditioned on x should be independent of the distribution of b conditioned on y. In maths this means that
P(a,b | x, y) = sum_i P(i) P(a|x, i) P(b|y,i)
Basically we're allowing the output bits to depend on some shared randomness P(i), but we're not allowing a to depend on y and we're not allowing b to depend on x. This is reasonable because we have the freedom to put x in a after we receive b from y, or vice-versa, or have them separated by arbitrary amounts of space, or whatever we like.
It turns out that the probability distribution P(a,b|x,y) that quantum mechanics predicts is not of this form. The probability distributions we observe in reality, when we actually do the experiment are also not of this form. This seems to mean that somehow, even if they're separated by arbitrary amounts of space, or done in whatever order you like, or whatever the output bit a does somehow depend on what input you give box B and vice-versa.
https://simple.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bell%27s_theorem
The book it's taken from is excellent
Basically what is happening is in some ways similar to what gives quantum computing its extra power compared to classical computers: as far as we can tell, quantities at the microscopic level are in fact complex numbers, and so combine in ways that give different values from the real-valued quantities we are used to from the classical world.