[0]: https://www.amazon.com/Steppe-Desert-Ocean-Birth-Eurasia/dp/...
[0]: https://www.amazon.com/Steppe-Desert-Ocean-Birth-Eurasia/dp/...
First he makes the interesting point that intelligence doesn't just evolve - it has to be for something; it must enhance survival or reproduction. So, what is intelligence good for?
He then argues how comparative advantage and division of labour is enormously beneficial. Also points to the pre-existing and unusual division of labour between men and women, as a starting point.
Now, once you have trade, you have all kinds of issues of accounting, cheating etc, which you do better at the cleverer you are - an additional driver for intelligence.
So, according to this theory, trade predates human intelligence.
There's more to be found at his blog (http://unenumerated.blogspot.com), this essay in particular is a good introduction:
I don't think any of this is wrong, but it reads oddly -- agriculture is older than the Bronze Age too, making the second sentence much weaker than the first one.
Agriculture is a technological invention, but its results are perishable and usually hard to transport. The idea of agriculture likely spred through already existing trade routes, but transporting food needed another technological advances to become reliable and profitable.
I always assumed the reverse because agriculture increases surpluses that lead to more births, more specialization (which leads to improved warfare vs hunter gatherers), and more land pressure that forces outward migration. AFAIK most of the hunter gatherers didn't convert to farmers, but they were squeezed out by those that did because they grew much more slowly. I didn't think cultural exchange was a major factor until much later when large agricultural societies started to colonize and "modernize" the rest of the planet.
The neolithic founder crops (rice, wheat, barley, flaxseed, various pulses) keep extremely well when whole or dried though.
In addition, the difference in food prices should cover the price of transportation and the risk of far journeys.
Obviously not. Most agriculture until very recently was of the subsistence variety. People want food to eat before they want trade goods.
I don't think this perspective squares well with the reality that starvation and malnutrition were realities for most people for most of history. I don't think it's just because they didn't think to do the extra bit of effort to generate a surplus. :)
> And you probably already grow more than you need anyway, so that you don't starve in bad years.
If you do grow enough to have such a reserve surplus, you don't trade that away or else you starve during the bad years. That surplus can only be either a reserve for hard times or currency for trade, but not both. If you want currency you have to have a surplus on top of your reserve.
> Seems to be that even subsistence agriculture will inevitably provoke some sort of economy, as long as other people are around.
"Subsistence" is kind of a confusing term because we use it in cases like feudal Europe where most people were subsisting because their surplus was being taken by their Lords. If you aren't generating a surplus at all, then you presumably don't get an agrarian economy (but you can still trade other things, like local minerals).
> I don't think this perspective squares well with the reality that starvation and malnutrition were realities for most people for most of history. I don't think it's just because they didn't think to do the extra bit of effort to generate a surplus.
There are different ways for something to be a reality of life. Starvation was a risk throughout history in a way that it isn't today. But it wasn't something that happened to people under normal circumstances. The historical norm involves paying a large portion of your crop as taxes. Starvation tends to happen to many people at once, due to bad weather or other inclement circumstances.
> If you do grow enough to have such a reserve surplus, you don't trade that away or else you starve during the bad years.
You do. You always grow enough to have a surplus. But you can't just sit on it indefinitely or it will rot. So you personally store enough for winter, part of your in-kind taxes go to fill public granaries (which need to be continually refreshed), and otherwise you attempt to dispose of any remaining surplus as you can, often by giving it away.
You're forgetting that people like to have kids, and those kids like to eat, too.
> And you probably already grow more than you need anyway, so that you don't starve in bad years.
IIRC, this problem was usually solved by having good relationships with your neighbors so they'd help you when you had a bad year. There's whole host of reasons why individualist solutions probably didn't work: e.g. storing surplus food for long periods using pre-modern technology is not as easy as it may seem.
> Seems to be that even subsistence agriculture will inevitably provoke some sort of economy, as long as other people are around.
But not necessarily a market economy.
Yes! that's exactly the point. That's an economy. You share your food with your neighbors when their harvest is bad, and vice versa. You also swap foods when you get bored. And the more people in your food-ring, the better it works, but also the more complex it becomes to keep track of, and eventually someone gets the bright idea to start writing it down, or swapping tokens...
It’s also worth noting that agriculture likely developed independently in China and certainly in the Americas. People crab about it a lot, but Guns, Germs, and Steel covers the development and spread of agriculture and other technologies pretty well, and the controversy seems to be more about alleged subtext than the actual facts presented.
It's not about subtext, it's about the actual text, namely GG&S's narrative, the thesis it purports to prove, and how it goes about doing that. GG&S is not an innocent list of facts and a recapitulation of historical events, if it were nobody would care about it.
In case you are actually interested in "the controversy", the /r/askhistorians FAQ has multiple comments on the subject: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/historians_views...
I get the distinct feeling that much of the criticisms are ultimately rooted in political differences. I don't think Diamond intends to be controversial or political, but I suspect the GG&S thesis chafes with the political narratives that have come to, shall we say, 'conquer' the humanities. Anyway, I can't prove it, and I don't have any interest in debating it--just something to keep in mind for anyone who is digging into GG&S criticisms.
and let do not forget New Guinea [1]
It would be interesting to know though, if trade networks enabled the easy transfer of know-how and technology, so a settlement might make use of that to increase their productivity and such.
Beyond that, the "why" of early urbanism is still fundamentally unclear. Some people, myself included, argue that there's no singular concrete reason that's universally applicable. Others take that a bit farther (e.g. Michael E. Smith) and argue that we need to invoke high level concepts of feedback loops and scaling laws to explain them. Regardless, there isn't a settled explanation in the literature.
It overturns many of the latent assumptions about early history, particularly in Mesopotamia. It's well argued, I recommend it. I listened to the audiobook FYI.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Against_the_Grain:_A_Deep_Hist...