0: https://medium.com/message/amazing-military-infographics-1ba...
0: https://medium.com/message/amazing-military-infographics-1ba...
Great article, despite the sardonic tone I found the graphics actually interesting, like something that would be read out loud and discussed on Jocko's podcast. That last line, however, reminded me of just how far we've taken it with systems that stalk targets from the sky for weeks to be used as evidence to authorize drone strikes.
https://www.wired.com/story/palantirs-gods-eye-view-of-afgha...
" After a while you realize that this image could be used anywhere in any paper or presentation and make perfect sense. This is a graphic that defines a way of describing anything that has ever existed and everything that has ever happened, in any situation."
Consultants are everywhere in the military. Especially the business / strategy / org behavior types. Anything the military does will have been done a hundred times before in industry — the military just needs it at goliath scale.
And if you're making million+ dollar bets on the basis of that philosophy, wouldn't it seem reasonable to pay six figures for a set of alternative philosophies to consider?
Or, in concrete terms, the CEO who is successful once because they were lucky vs the CEO who has decades of success in wildly different environments, because they learned alternatives and chose the most apt at any time.
John Boyd was an Air Force officer who came up with the OODA loop theory. Basically, a pilot in air combat loops through the stages of Observe, Orient, Decide, and Act, and if a pilot is capable of iterating through this loop faster than their opponent, they win. Some people realized this same theory could actually explain combat more generally (particularly maneuver warfare) as well as business and everyday life.
John Boyd's magnum opus was a slide presentation of several hundred slides, which took several hours to present, which he never allowed to be abridged or summarized in any way.
John Boyd was influential and I don't even think he was a complete crackpot, but the military's tendency to overuse PowerPoint and develop vague theories-of-everything as their operational doctrines reminds me of him. I don't think they pull it off as well as he did.
I think you're referring to Patterns of Conflict[1] which is/was 187 slides plus around 9 slides of sources. The funny thing is that Patterns is mostly comprised of dense text, not diagrams or pictures. It was a lot of fun trying to absorb Boyd's ideas if one can find the presentations online. They are quite a contrast to (publicly available) military briefings and papers these days given the lower text-to-visuals ratio.
Chuck Spinney and Chet Richards worked with Boyd, as did Ginger Richards, on various major briefings. To your point, most of them are 40+ pages/slides each.
[0]: https://web.archive.org/web/20210414195621/http://www.ausair...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9TpFQuBY8E0
Nearly 5.5 hours!
Standalone modern slides, almost 200 pages:
http://www.projectwhitehorse.com/pdfs/boyd/patterns%20of%20c...
Alternate modern slides with PiP presentation of same presentation as above, but in separate parts, but best audio IMO, with auto-generated captions, typos included:
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL4pmLxkc7CTcukIlpD0UThT7Y...
The story behind the original uploader getting the source videos which were uploaded in separate parts, which have been remastered and combined since:
https://medium.com/@jasonmbro/uploading-john-boyd-4264b82d73...
Original slides:
https://geekboss.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/patterns-of-...
via
https://geekboss.com/boyd-patterns-of-conflict/
Which seems to link to an alternate version of the talk in four parts, but which is not exhaustive or complete as above versions.
[edit] which reminds me of the IDF/Deleuze thing - the grand insight they got from reading Difference & Repetition was that... they could blow holes in walls instead of going around them https://www.metamute.org/editorial/articles/art-war-deleuze-...
The other part is these "theories of war" become vehicles for self advancement. These become almost cult like fads within the pentagon. Then a few years later the new fad takes over. Remember "Shock and Awe?" Don't hear much about that anymore do we...
From a game theory perspective, groups are incentivized to advertise (and hopefully popularize) their positions.
Individuals are then incentivized to align and advertise their allegiance with either popular or up-and-coming positions.
The end result... exactly what we see.
(And it's not like this isn't present in tech via cargo cultism either)
But that's the case for a lot of things. REPL and OODA fall into that category of philosophies that are simple once presented, but we needed someone to recognize as existing. And there is a benefit to recognizing these patterns as they allow us to optimize them.
Also, things that get independently discovered in several places are more likely to be correct as they seem to be naturally emergent.