Thoughtful critique is welcome of course. It's cheap flamewar rhetoric that we don't want here. If you feel that another comment is a shallow dismissal, a substantive reply showing how that is the case can be quite helpful.
The comment you are responding to also explicitly points out the basis being just the article in question, and being open to the possibility of a better argument posed in the book. So, I honestly do not see the issue here.
edit: As is evident from the response they got, the book seems to give better insights, which must be a win for everyone?
Admitting that you did not checked it and being theoretically open to change if you would bothered does not change all that much. Plus, this is just how bias works. In assumptions claim when you don't check evidence.
(I agree the root comment was a bit... weird, let's put it that way, but the author themselves acknowledged that)
I did not flagged the comment nor downvoted it. I responded to claim that it was win. Which responded to claim that the comment took offense.