Hacker News Reader

Comment by raylad | Hacker News Reader

It says:

"Find My Network: Participating in the Find My network lets you locate this iPhone even if its offline"

So in fact there is no option (there at least) to opt out of finding other people's AirTags unless you also want to opt out of finding your own iPhone, at least as stated.

View on HN

Which is entirely fair, don’t you think? If you want to make use of the ability to find your phone while it’s powered off, you should help others to do the same.

Or is it the airtag functionality specifically that’s bothering you?

> Or is it the airtag functionality specifically that’s bothering you?

A phone is bigger, more visible, and expensive if someone would want to use it to track you. Not practical at all.

Maybe they should have 2 options: Phone and Tags (or All). Enabling find my phone would not necessarily allow tags.

> Or is it the airtag functionality specifically that’s bothering you?

Yes. What does find my phone have to do with airtags?

You can still have traditional Find My- the one where your phone connects and tells Apple where its GPS is. This switch is specifically for the networking, which allows other devices to help out when your phone is dead or otherwise not connected to the internet/gps.

But i wouldn't mind helping people find their phones, but i would want to opt out of airtags. I'm not mooching because i don't have any airtags.

If it has no impact on you, why would you want to opt out of the airtag tracking?

If you were known to be the only person who frequents an area, then an adversary's Airtag planted there getting updated would notify them that you were present.

In this extremely specific case where people are planting airtags to track you, you can simply disable the feature as the parent mentions.

Are ya'll trying to invent the dumbest sounding scenarios or is that inadvertent?

"I don't use that freeway so I don't want to pay for the maintenance"

Either you use the roads and pay for all the roads or you don't.

That's a terrible analogy. I don't allow android devices to use my "ios roads" as it is. Why does it matter if i don't want airtags to mooch off my network? It's not like airtags are providing their share of network back to me.

It is a network effect. Because people buy and use AirTags, they turn on their FindMy, which in turn benefits you when you want someone to find your own iPhone.

Everyone interested in finding their lost or stolen iPhone already turned it on. AirTags will bring up another small percentage of people. The sum of everything available to you, means you have this small price to pay to be part of it: contributing to finding stuff for others.

There’s no such a thing as small price to pay attached to privacy. You either have it or you don’t.

What privacy are you losing by enabling the Find My Network?

The specs are here: https://manuals.info.apple.com/MANUALS/1000/MA1902/en_US/app...

Page 139 onwards.

If you can find a security/privacy hole in the spec, I think Apple will compensate you pretty well.

Thanks for your link, but I will start here -> https://arxiv.org/abs/2103.02282

> While we find that OF's design achieves its privacy goals, we discover two distinct design and implementation flaws that can lead to a location correlation attack and unauthorized access to the location history of the past seven days, which could deanonymize users. Apple has partially addressed the issues following our responsible disclosure. Finally, we make our research artifacts publicly available.

Not something a regular dude off the street will be doing any time soon. =)

That's... not true. Privacy is definitely shades of grey, as everything is.

> is it the airtag functionality specifically that’s bothering you?

Yes.

That's because it's using the same "network" to track both. It wouldn't make sense to turn one off an not the other. When your device is offline it's acting just like the AirTags and pulling info from other nearby iphones.

I think if you’re making use of the network, it’s entirely fair to ask you to contribute to it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com