https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solid_oxide_electrolyzer_cell
High temperature operation is what allows it to have such high conversion efficiency.
http://www.helmeth.eu/index.php/technologies/high-temperatur...
Don't see that being practical for vehicle use any time soon.
Makes more sense to look at heat recovery turbines for a diesel engine which is exactly what Freightliner is doing with their Supertruck bringing its thermal efficiency up around 60%.
And no, the complexity of heat recovery isn't high at all. The costs pay themselves off almost immediately. They're orders of magnitude less complex than an ICE, last almost forever, and require almost no maintenance apart from cleaning after tens of thousands of hours. If a modern heat recovery turbine is too complex, then so is an electric motor.
Heat recovery turbines use either organic Rankine cycle (steam turbine) or Brayton where the fuel cell replaces or is along side the combustion chamber in a gas turbine.
Comparing the complexity of a Heat recovery turbine to an electric motor is absurd. Let me know when a SOFC with recovery turbine is in a truck.
I don't see a lot of gas turbines in various use around me, and the ones that are are quite expensive to fix. I do however see electric motors everywhere and they are extremely reliable and cheap.
They're called turbochargers. More specifically, the heat recovery turbine is the exhaust-connected half of the turbocharger. Most car turbos drive air compressors to increase ICE efficiency (surplus electric power isn't so useful for ICE cars), but you can literally chop the turbocharger in half and attach an electric motor to the turbine shaft, and voila, now you have an electric heat recovery turbine.
Were you actually thinking I was proposing attaching a steam turbine to a fuel cell? Lol. Can I subscribe to the Cult of Elon's Version of Facts? This is hilarious.
In order to utilize the increased air mass that forced induction creates more fuel must be injected, this should be obvious. Most turbo chargers do not engage under light throttle.
Turbo charger also adds significant cost and are not inexpensive to repair.
An actual useful heat recovery turbine is much larger and more complicated, all of the examples of one attached to diesels or fuel cell are either steam turbines as is the case with the Freightliner SuperTruck [1] or full gas turbines as is the case with some fuel cell implementations and some of those also have a secondary steam turbine [2].
The Freightliner still has a turbo charger like any diesel along with a recovery steam turbine, much of the effective heat recovery comes from capturing heat from the engine block itself not just hot exhaust gas.
Again your claim that a full heat recovery turbine is a simple as a electric motor is ABSURD.
1. https://www.ccjdigital.com/business/article/14931733/waste-h...
2. https://www.ee.co.za/article/co-generation-hybrid-fuel-cell-...
This is 100% false, and trivially easy to google. But it also misses the point: turbochargers are heat engines: they convert heat to work. The fact that they use waste heat from exhaust means that they recover energy that is normally lost, which means it is a heat recovery engine. That work can be used any number of ways, but if it is used, you have increased the thermal efficiency of the engine.
> The Freightliner still has a turbo charger like any diesel along with a recovery steam turbine, much of the effective heat recovery comes from capturing heat from the engine block itself not just hot exhaust gas.
Those are both heat recovery engines. One is rankine cycle (the steam turbine), and the other is brayton cycle (the turbocharger). The only other difference is the source of heat.
And again, to drive the point home: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S187661021...
Turbochargers allow more efficiency through engine downsizing and that they can be bypassed under light/cruising loads. That is you can have smaller engine that acts like a bigger engine under heavy loads but has the efficiency of a smaller engine at normal loads [2].
The turbo charger on the Frieghtliner is not part of the heat recovery system, it is compressing intake air in order to allow an increase of power by also injecting more fuel. If you attach a generator to the turbo to make it recover heat as output power it will no longer be able to use that work to compress intake air. Then it becomes a turbo-compounded engine. They use a steam turbine as it recovers more heat while adding almost no back pressure to the system.
As shown to get a modest increase in thermal efficiency something much larger and more complicated must be used on a semi in addition to the turbocharger.
Show me a fuel cell using a turbo charger to attain any significant heat recovery. Show me one that doesn't use a generator and is therefore simpler than an electric motor. You will not attain 60%+ thermal efficiency with a just a turbo charger and you know it. Fuel cells look to need a secondary combustion system in order drive the turbine properly due to them having no compression of their own so now you have a full gas turbine with generator on top of the fuel cell.
1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turbo-compound_engine 2. http://large.stanford.edu/courses/2010/ph240/veltman1/
And no, it is not complex at all. The turbine part stays the same as your garden variety turbocharger. Instead of directly attaching a compressor (which makes it a turbocharger), you directly attach a generator (which makes it a turbine-driven generator). In fact, you could even do both: power an intake air compressor as well as a generator. Literally anybody could build one in their back yard using parts ripped out of random cars at a junkyard.
Without capturing any waste heat at all, Solid Oxide Fuel Cells are ~60% efficient. With a waste heat recovery turbine, you increase the efficiency. 75% efficiency is already feasible.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03062...
Yes, this solution is more complex than a normal fuel cell...in exactly the same way that a turbocharged engine is more complex than a naturally aspirated engine. That is to say not only is it entirely feasible, but it is a well developed easily adaptible solution that has been used for increasing efficiency for over a century now. Learn how to google...there are literally hundreds of papers detailing efficiency gains from using turbochargers on fuel cells. Hell, most turbocharger manufacturers are already making custom hybrid turbocharger/generator packages specifically designed for fuel cell use.
https://www.garrettmotion.com/electric-hybrid/twostage-elect... https://www.mtu-solutions.com/eu/en/stories/technology/turbo... https://cdn.borgwarner.com/docs/default-source/default-docum...
You thought it was infeasible because you were imagining a big ass steam engine, and when it was pointed out that turbochargers are an entirely commonplace form of heat recovery turbine, you backpeddled and tried to redefine words (b-b-b-but that's a Turbo Compounder!!!) to weasel your way out of it. Give it up. You're embarrassing yourself.
A generator is bascially an electric motor running in reverse, at minimum you have a turbine and a generator to make a heat recovery turbine, or you can mechanically couple it with a transmission. That is more complex than just an electric motor, is this not obvious to you?
The SOFC you linked at 75% efficiency uses a turbine with a secondary combustion chamber (post combustor) and along with a generator. Again this is not just a "simple" turbocharger.
https://d3i71xaburhd42.cloudfront.net/3362b2a27c2ec1f3064114...
Does that look like just a simple turbo charger?
You are the one redefining what a heat recovery turbine is, no one calls a turbo charger a heat recovery turbine, and no devices called heat recovery turbines are just a turbo charger at minimum they drive a generator or are mechanically coupled to an engines output.
So you have on one hand a:
battery - motor controller - electric motor
VS
high pressure liquid H2 tanks - fuel cell - recovery turbine with generator - motor controller - electric motor
Hopefully the fuel cell can have enough burst power for acceleration and not also need a buffer battery like current fuel cell EV's, then again you need a battery or regenerative braking, oh well.
Which one is simpler and cheaper to fuel, maintain and operate? Which has more moving parts? Current fuel cells in cars don't even have an energy density advantage, maybe they will and will outpace batteries but they are certainly not simpler than a battery powered EV.
Also stop being an ass, you are the one embarrassing yourself, at least try and keep it civil.
It doesn't look like a turbocharger, it looks like a system diagram of a fuel cell attached to a turbocharger.
::facepalm::
> You are the one redefining what a heat recovery turbine is, no one calls a turbo charger a heat recovery turbine, and no devices called heat recovery turbines are just a turbo charger at minimum they drive a generator or are mechanically coupled to an engines output.
::doublefacepalm::
Is a gas turbine sitting next to an engine being fed half the fuel and putting out half the power a turbo charger?
Did you miss the combustion chamber and generator for the gas turbine when you face-palmed?
The Garrett link you presented isn't even a heat recovery turbine, it's just a electric compressor it draws electrical power from the fuel cell to compress the air. The other links are similar, they actually use power rather than generating it, they allow reduction in fuel cell size not increased efficiency:
"The process temperature of modern fuel cells for cars is rather low. Therefore, the exhaust gas enthalpy provided to the turbine is not sufficient to drive the compressor. Hence, a powerful electrical motor is necessary to drive the compressor; in fact, it is an essential component of the FCAS system. Even a variant of the FCAS system without a turbine is available as part of the FCAS family."
A turbo charger compresses air using heat, then rejects much of that heat in the intercooler very little of it is recovered as engine output power. Its purpose is to increase volumetric efficiency not thermal efficiency. More air + more fuel = more power with less displacement.
A heat recovery turbine increases thermal efficiency not volumetric efficiency, that is the distinction between a turbo charger and heat recovery turbine in all literature I can find. They operate on similar principles and share a component (the turbine) but one is simpler than the other and they are not the same.
Please show me a fuel cell using just a "simple" off the self turbocharger as a heat recovery turbine.