Hacker News Reader

Personally I think "programming" RTL is dead simple. It's so simple, in fact, that it's not even interesting. But I've been doing it forever so my perspective is skewed.

View on HN

I think you are thinking of different types of tasks. A lot of RTL is brainless, but if you are actually trying to compute with it, it can get tough.

A mediocre C++ programmer can write a (bad) hash table in C++ in a few hours. How fast can you give me one in Verilog?

You're not writing a hash table in verilog, you're writing a hardware configuration that can hold and manipulate a hash table. It's a different ball game.

I have to make a lot of assumptions, but a couple hours doesn't seem unreasonable for the core function. Among the many assumptions are the hash function, what is actually being hashed, what processor interface is, desired performance, etc.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com