> I think Ethereum 2.0 is currently demonstrating at scale that proof of stake works fine and can be secure against hordes of very incentivized hackers trying to cheat. That should hopefully bury the whole proof of stake is centralized argument.
This is really shakey ground to prop up an argument in favor of cryptocurrency: AFAICT no cryptocurrency ever dies until people stop trading it, which virtually never happens.
I’m reminded of the saga of “stable coins” — stable coins of the non-IOU sort. Every major example of one has imploded at least once during times of high market volatility, no exceptions. Including as recently as 2020. You’d think after enough of these implosions the concept would be disproven on a fundamental level, but no.
(Many have considered these unstable stablecoins theoretically unsound ever since the concept’s inception — bitUSD IIRC — with clear parallels to PoS.)
Developers and VCs have been deeply invested in PoS consensus for many years now, mostly because they were attractive financial bets to make. There’s no use in my even opining on the theoretical flaws of PoS, because implosions of cryptocurrencies seem to not even matter to investors.
Anyway, at some point, the people funding and developing these PoS systems evidently shifted into abject promotion mode for obvious financially motivated reasons based on really nothing aside from investor expectations. Nothing has ever been proven about PoS aside from the fact traders are willing to hold speculative positions in these coins — no different from the reasons they’ve held any other cryptocurrency. And even if PoS were a fundamentally discredited concept disproven as many times over as “unstable stablecoins” have been, it would change absolutely nothing about investor behaviour.