Inequality Would Widen If U.S. Policies Spur Sustained Inflation
wsj.com
wsj.com
I have a new theory that the difference between 1970s style inflation in the US and what we would see today is that the main thing that would be inflated would be stock valuations, which also favor the wealthy. As recently as the 90s [0], slightly more than 30% of Americans owned stocks, while now that number is over 50%. I couldn't find data going back earlier , but I wouldn't be surprised if only 10% of Americans owned stocks in the 1970s. This was before ETFs and the E-Trade revolution.
In the 1970s if people saw a windfall they would likely buy more consumer goods, driving up the prices. But now they will likely just but financial assets, everything from Bitcoin to GameStop to ETFs. So we're seeing inflation in asset prices, but we don't consider that inflation since its associated with a booming healthy economy.
It's unfortunate that the Fed officials don't see run-away asset price inflation as a consequence of growth in the monetary base
[0] https://qz.com/1700958/more-americans-own-stock-than-ever/
I see this repeated so often but people fail to grasp the nuance. If you buy stocks, someone else gets your money and they have the inflation problem. If that someone else is part of the middle class or below then you already won because rich people sent their money to less rich people. If that someone is another rich person, then that person will be stuck with the inflation problem. The only way you can avoid the inflation problem by buying stocks is if the company whose stock you are buying from sells you the stock, and then uses the money to do business, which usually involves hiring people and most people care more about having good jobs (i.e. a 20% raise), than seeing the rich gain 4% on their portfolio.
You can’t just redefine inflation to say it means inflation of stock prices.
I'm not a federal reserve basher, I understand the purpose. But some policies they promoted have resulted in unaffordable housing and those with assets already becoming extremely wealthy while the lower tiers increasingly struggle to get by.
Perhaps in sum the policies have made the nation more wealthy or improved GDP numbers, so perhaps it's a tradeoff they felt worthwhile (or else they inherited a situation which left them with little choice).
Stan Drukenmiller gave an interview about this recently.
Negotiating power depends on how close you are to full employment. If an increase in inflation results in more employment then you will get closer to full employment and over the long term you can use your newly gained negotiating power to get wages that outpace inflation.
One problem right now is that things like gas price increases don't meaningfully contribute employment, they are just a short term inflation spike that is going away. i.e. it's stagflation caused by a supply shock
Price inflation might not, and attempts to suppress price inflation while continuing money supply inflation may make inequalty worse.
Inflation is a way governments can borrow money at one valuation, pay it back at another lower valuation. And it helps smooth over rough patches in things like public sector pension funds (at the expense of those who were expecting to receive pensions with a different buying power then they receive).
Some amount of controlled inflation helps move the economy along. Complete lack of inflation usually means no growth. But it's always a transferal of real wealth from one group to the other.
It's not driven by the federal reserve because they filled up bank reserves and dropped interest rates a long time ago.
Biden is a factor because he is restoring consumer confidence but that alone isn't enough, it would only explain roughly 2-3% of the inflation numbers. The BLS CPI shows 2.4% inflation for food 25% for energy and 3% for everything else (apparently cars are a big driver of prices). Total inflation is 4.2%.
It's definitively related to the transportation industry. Having no chips to build new cars is clearly a bad thing and something weird is happening with gasoline.
This is not good in the short term but there is also absolutely no reason for it to remain like this in the long term. i.e. hyperinflation is a risky bet unless China or Russia attack semiconductor fabs or major oil suppliers
Recommend to watch the Drukenmiller interview in my other comment below. (https://twitter.com/i/status/1393965498618978308)
Hyperinflation is unlikely in the short run because historically the bubble deflates rapidly before it occurs. If that happens what do we suppose the fed and Biden administration will do? Then maybe we see more inflation then can reasonably be expected in the short term.