Opinions like these (I stop one step short of calling them findings, as this is speculation either way) resonate with me. I'm, too, more convinced by the Rare Earth hypothesis, and I find it quite plausible that we're indeed the sole sentient lifeform in the Universe - at least throughout the time of our existence.
This belief never gained me much popularity though. And this is what I'm fascinated about - how badly a lot of people take to this view. Even seemingly rational individuals seem to have some deeply ingrained, emotional need to defend the belief in ETI.
My personal theory is that this emotional mechanism is actually of religious nature; just in disguise. It's very telling that the most popular narratives involving ETI are usually quasi-religious.
The aliens would typically "teach us how to live in peace" (if we're willing to sit down and listen, of course), or turn away from us in disgust (for our sins), or scold us for our poor moral judgment and deeds; generally trap us in shame. Or they'd be quite diabolical and bring all sorts of plagues upon us, giving us a taste of our own medicine for we're wicked.
But the eschatological component is rarely absent either way.
Even this sceptical paper uses biased language through and through, consistently referring to the belief in the prevalence of ETI as "optimistic", and calling the opposite belief "pessimistic". But why?