I suspect this thought experiment is overly simplistic to the point of not being useful. Person A has $50k worth of BTC. Person B has $50k worth of cash (some % of which they got from the stimulus). So now 'the room' has $100k in assets. A and B exchange their assets. A+B still equals $100k. $BTC drops by $15k. A+B=$85k. There is now $85k in assets in the room. $15k was lost.