This is a really bold statement for any analysis and seems odd to come put of academic work that’s supervised.
This preprint is submitted to the Journal of Palestinian Studies so it will be interesting to see how their peer review checks this out.
I don’t quite understand this conclusion based on the paper as it seems like the author looked for existence of some words and for use of active vs passive voice.
I don’t understand how active vs passive voice is a sign of bias unless you control for many other factors not mentioned. Are specific authors more likely, is time period affected, are other topics similar, etc etc. I don’t get the logic that this shows a bias in general and don’t see anything presented about why these 33k articles are different.
Similarly, I’m not sure how tracking the mention of Palestinian or Israeli people just by word count means anything. Wouldn’t this be impacted by events, this isn’t addressed in the paper. Are there more deaths or attacks in different groups. This seems important to address, but I couldn’t find anything. I’m also not sure how the 33k articles were selected so whether articles were included or excluded would impact these results.
Similarly not sure if the sentiment analysis of the NLP kits she used is similar or dissimilar from NYT in general.
And the determination of violent language seems like a manual exercise with no validation and would like to know more about the methods used to create the set of violent words. I don’t see the actual training_data.csv that the author created and would be interested to see what was actually made since that file seems to be the output of a manual process to sample 500 articles and pick words.