Then please elaborate why we should accept said premise. You just state it like it's an universal law of the universe. It isn't. No artisan (or actually, no one at all) is entitled to a successful business modell.
And by the way, the "problem" aren't the people who are unwilling to pay for anything (which I am sure you or someone else will cite sooner or later). It's the people expecting to make money with art. It's cool if you can. If you can't, then you're not entitled to laws or monopolies that protect your failed business modell.
>Are you prepared to argue that Ace did Tolkien no harm?
Why should it have? More people were able to read his beautiful works. Are you prepared to argue how that constitutes as harm in the first place?