Yes this is easily separable from making productivity tools.
I think the people who brought the pyramid into the equation were pointing out how individual behaviors, in aggregate, lead to greater possibilities of increased oppression. I think it’s a simplification to say that they lead to genocide, because those sorts of results are dependent on many other factors (ie economic problems, political instability, etc). When combined, these factors result in greater oppression.
More apropos to the conversation regarding workplaces, I would consider them evolving into institutions where certain cultural norms are upheld. The more institutions within which a certain cultural norm is respected by individuals, the more other people/institutions in power have leeway to move in certain directions.
[1] https://www.adl.org/sites/default/files/documents/pyramid-of...
Minor footnote is a straw man and false dichotomy. The graphic is about all the things like I said. It wouldn't be less about genocide if it was an escalating list. It isn't less about biased attitudes because it's a pyramid.
I don’t think I accept this theory. But if I did, it’s not relevant because the list wasn’t making fun of “others” and seemed to have no correlation to any particular vulnerable population.
So it’s both an issue of an arguable diagram in the first place (even if the ADL created it) introduced in a place that was not relevant since there were very few Asian names on the list yet the discussion seemed to really get into racial issues that didn’t apply to the situation.
Of course, had employees been mocking or belittling people because of their race or the list was 94% Asian (instead of the 94% euro) then it’s a different story and the discussion would be very different. But that’s not “woke” that’s just enforcing ethical codes in employees to not discriminate based on race.
You could make a pyramid where you have violent movies and playing violent video games leads to a person becoming a serial killer arguing that violent movies and video games desensitize you to murder.
These despots were even very open about their plans and methodologies. Hitler specifically cited as inspirations the United States’ systematic oppression and genocide of indigenous peoples, and the Ottomans’ oppression and genocide of Armenians.
This stuff has never happened in a vacuum. Anyone who insists on always arguing from first principles is—most charitably—being a useful idiot for those who know exactly what they’re trying to do.
As an outsider, what it looks like happened at Basecamp was:
1. Some people did something insensitive. Not great, but not the end of the world.
2. Some people - possibly overlapping the previous group - call out that said activity is insensitive, and ask for it to stop. Possibly not in the politest way possible, but also not starting fights.
3. A right-wing extremist in a position of power gets bent out of shape and uses his position of power to say that racism doesn't real, and that microaggressions are pretty cool, actually.
4. Chaos ensues. CEO doesn't immediately tell right-wing extremist to fuck off, and instead thanks him for his contributions - which, while understandable in the heat of the moment, isn't a good look for him... especially since he has no deniability about already knowing extremist's true colors.
5. Rather than taking sides between slightly over-enthusiastic concerned employees and right-wing extremism, CEO says that all politics are now off limits, which makes it sound like both sides were equally at fault. Right-wing extremist's position is thus legitimized, which is likely all he wanted in the first place.