Some things that Fuchsia was able to do thanks to starting from scratch:
- The system is based on capabilities, a security model which is based on explicit tracking of permissions. It wouldn't be possible to change Linux to be capability-based because the ambiant-authority model has been used pervasively since it was conceived 30 years ago.
- Fuchsia provides a stable binary interface (like Windows, but unlike Linux). This lets you update your system while keeping some components unchanged, eg. binary drivers from a hardware manufacturer that wouldn't provide updates for them anymore. I think Linux could technically change this, but they have historically been unwilling to, and it is unlikely to change in the future.
Linux does provide a stable binary interface, to userspace.
> eg. binary drivers from a hardware manufacturer that wouldn't provide updates for them anymore
That can be seen as much as a downside as an upside, because it makes life a lot easier for hardware manufacturers to ship more binary blobs
Which is essentially the point of this approach for Google, to exert greater control.
When the goal is, to support a broad range of devices - and the vast majority of hardware manufactors are not into open hardware - it is probably easier, to convince them of supporting Fuchsia by writing firmware and drivers - if they do not have to deal with the GPL and the kernel driver integration, like it is the case with linux. They just write their driver once against a stable API.
That makes things easier.
And google are not driven by free software ideals - but rather buisness pragmatism. But I don't see this design choice as an attack on free software.
I dont think it would be fair to call Fuchsia a step backwards in this respect - vendors that ship closed source binaries for Fuchsia are almost certainly shipping closed source binaries for Linux as well.
Linux tried different things to reload dynamically the drivers & core stuff, without rebooting the computer, but I always had diverse issues after some hours...
Thanks for the link + info :)
Does it?
Fuchsia is a brand new OS, at least from the perspective of the world. One reason my interest in it died quite early on, despite being an aficionado of new operating system designs my entire life, was finding stuff like this in the docs:
https://fuchsia.dev/fuchsia-src/development/components/v2/mi...
It's brand new and there are already migration guides for core parts of the design. Also:
https://fuchsia.dev/s/results?q=deprecated
That's a lot of deprecated stuff for a project that started with a blank slate.
But now with the official release - I do expect some stability.