Hacker News Reader

Comment by JMTQp8lwXL | Hacker News Reader

I've found GitLab as a product to be more difficult to use than GitHub. The pages seem more dense with lots of color, many more actions: they just feel busy. Basic features, like getting a permalink to a line of code, take 3-4 clicks in GitLab, when it's just 1 in GitHub.

View on HN

> Basic features, like getting a permalink to a line of code, take 3-4 clicks in GitLab, when it's just 1 in GitHub

That doesn't seem right.

In Gitlab: Right click the line number, choose Copy Link in the context menu. Two clicks.

In Github: Click the line, click the three dots, then click "Copy permalink". Three clicks. Alternatively, click the line, click the URL bar (or press F6 or ^L) copy the link. Still Three clicks.

What's the one-click method in GitHub I'm missing?

What's different is you get functionally different links. GitLab aliases to the branch name, not the commit hash. So it isn't really a "permanent" link to a line of code. It's whatever happens to be on line N in file X on branch Y at time T, whenever you open the link. This is inconvenient when I might find an old link in an engineering Slack thread, referencing something now much different since the file was amended over time. In fact, the file may not even exist anymore.

GitHub, by default, includes the commit hash. So the line of code will be the same at any point in the future: the file, at that line number, with that commit hash, is immutable (unless developers force push history rewrites, but you get my broader point).

To do this in GitLab, click the permalink button before copying the line.

I'm going to share the feedback on page density, colors, and actions with our team.

To copy a link to a line of code, you can hover over the number next to the line of code and then copy a link to that line.

I created a gif to show what I mean: https://gitlab.com/johncoghlan/blog/-/raw/master/images/perm...

Coming from bitbucket I find gitlab design too busy as well and missing some basic obvious functionality which could be there but it's not intuitive. For example, when viewing a merge request I can't find a way to copy the target branch name.

Hi! You can copy the branch name at the bottom of the right sidebar with one click: https://i.imgur.com/O3StMBA.png

Or in the merge request widget, below the description: https://i.imgur.com/V72v9jj.png

that's the source branch. I am looking for a way to copy the target/destination branch name.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com