Sure, there were horrible industrial disasters like Bhopal, but in the book the aforementioned megacorp kills millions seemingly out of sheer evil. It felt too videogamey for my taste.
Sure, there were horrible industrial disasters like Bhopal, but in the book the aforementioned megacorp kills millions seemingly out of sheer evil. It felt too videogamey for my taste.
And I don't just mean literal gold or mining.. The Internet in the late 90s and early 2000s, cryptocurrency today, etc... there will always be early adopters and entrepreneurial risk-takers (of varying levels of competency) who precede, and sometimes outlast, the corporations where there's money to be made..
In the Expanse lore, this happened because of the Epstein drive, a relatively cheap type of fusion drive that allowed humanity to go further faster, even in small scrappy ships.
So it would make sense that early pioneers would rush out to the belt and beyond to stake their claims..
Look at mining in the third world today. Not so automated, right? Why would it be any different out in the belt?
Hundreds of years and millions of people trying to eke out a living, particularly when you also consider the state of planet Earth in the Expanse (essentially a giant welfare state).. that creates an third-world equivalent out there, and I think it's pretty plausible..
Anyways, I respect your take on things regardless.. this is just mine.. the story gets so much better beyond book 1, if you're ever thinking about reconsidering. :-)
Incidentally, can anyone recommend some hopeful science fiction? "Schismatrix" is probably my favorite.
Worth noting that Earth isn't part of the Culture, it has been left in ignorance to stare out at an apparently silent universe.
The humanoids that populate the Culture belong to any number of entirely unrelated species that are capable of interbreeding through deliberate interventions (upgrades, really) that paper over the genetic, proteomic, biochemical, etc. differences.
None of those species are related to Earth's Homo Sapiens, or to any other species belonging to Earth's biosphere (though I think there might have been an allusion or two to panspermia insofar as origin-of-life goes).
So. When I say that Earth isn't part of the Culture, I mean to include anyone who has any Earth ancestors.
OTOH, the Culture has had observers, agents, etc. visit Earth (after being appropriately retrofitted to resemble Earth humans at least anatomically, and optionally biochemically and genetically) on occasion, to determine whether to continue with the policy of nonintervention. In the Culture books published so far, the policy holds.
The authors have said they approached each book in the style of the characters and story they were telling at that time.
The first book is a noir detective novel (that happens to be set in space and in the future) so I can definitely see how it comes across as bleak..
The next book and beyond are written in different styles.
Thanks for the Schimatrix recommendation! I'd never heard of it, and I looked it up.. Added it to my reading list!
I might recommend The Inverted Frontier series by Linda Nagata to you, that I've only just started... It's pretty good and I think falls under the hopeful sci-fi category (at least so far). :-)
I wish they made more sci-fi about robots and spaceships, I find that stuff entertaining and inspiring. If I want social commentary I have better sources than sci-fi writers.
And there is Sci-Fi that's not social commentary.
> And there is Sci-Fi that's not social commentary.
I'm not sure that this is true. I think you might be confusing the Action and Adventure genres with Sci-Fi. Star Trek, for example, is almost 100% social commentary.
It is certainly educational though, and to me, The Martian is rather in the category of “competence porn”
If mental and long-term health is not a concern, minimal-subsistence living conditions can be made for pennies. If someone snaps or drops-out, they can be replaced from thousands of others on the long application list.
Not unlikely, I'd say.
From what I've seen, cost of living will increase to the maximum level the poorest can afford it (which is why I don't see how UBI can work without massive changes in other areas).
With a laissez-faire system, the economic factors would decide whether machine or man labor is the most cost effective resource. When the mechanized means of production become more intelligent, faster, and accurate, what can the man or woman without any machines of their own do for money? They could work for less than the machines in dangerous conditions, doing the type of work that machines are too valuable for.
The optimist can also imagine a utopia where the need to labor vanishes and we collectively benefit from advances in science and technology, but that’s not a given.
Read more history and you'll see this is pretty much SOP for humans.
My favorite line from Sorry To Bother You.
> So, you making half-human half-horse fucking things so you can make more money?
> Yeah, basically. I just didn't want you to think I was crazy. That I was doing this for no reason. Because this isn't irrational.