Matt Gaetz: Americans have an 'obligation' to take up arms against SV companies
businessinsider.com
businessinsider.com
When the conversation completely breaks down, violence is the remaining option, and we shouldn't be surprised people go down what they perceive as the only remaining possibility. We need empathy now more than ever.
People like Matt Gaetz are fascists, and fascists thrive on projecting a aura of menace and intimidation and righteousness and cultivating a sense of respect and authority that justifies their violent ideology. The way to fight that is to ridicule and humiliate them, to make it clear that society has no place for their brutality and foolishness.
Still, I’ll agree that we shouldn’t be living in the days of tribal warfare and duels of honor. I’ll wait with anticipation for your ridicule and humiliation of those wayward urban teens. Somehow I suspect your choice of targets is a little more...tribal?
I think you are downplaying what is going on. Did you forget social media banned POTUS? Millions of people voted for this person, and that banned caused extreme division in the U.S. (I think that was the plan, but that's a different matter). If he was so dangerous and a dictator, why did he step down!? One side is alienating millions of people, calling them names, and shutting them down. What do you think will happen? They will just take it with a smile? (please answer this, it's an important question, how should they take it?)
> fascists thrive on projecting a aura of menace and intimidation and righteousness and cultivating a sense of respect and authority that justifies their violent ideology
What is the end goal? The rhetoric you're using isn't going to end with both sides drinking tea and chatting together. Is that what people want? Let's keep insulting them and provoking them until they break and then AHA! there it is! They are being violent! Got 'em!
If we add fuel to the fire, we are provoking, and we are no better than the violent people. If you don't acknowledge these are humans with genuine concerns, then you are dehumanizing them, and again, we shouldn't be surprised where that goes.
Imagine I walk up to someone and insult them to their face and when they try and defend themselves verbally they are shutdown and not able to speak by a mob around them. This keeps happening again and again and that person starts to visibly get flustered and wanting to fight. I then justify my insults by pointing out how this person likes to fight and is probably a violent, dangerous individual... what should I expect? Should I be surprised when they punch me in the face?
One side is provoking, and bullying people, then shutting them down, and then complaining that they are becoming more and more extreme, while using that as a justification. At some point we have to realize, we are asking for this and pretending to be innocent. Saying that they have a choice, is disingenuous.
I see both sides wanting violence, but only one side is being honest about it.
That's fine, let me just clarify, I don't condone Gaetz (I've only heard of him) or what he is saying, and I don't condone any violence or call for it (and I'm trying to prevent it as much as I can).
I am able to see both extremes quite clearly. I think both extremes are wanting violence, but only one side is being direct about it. Ridiculing them is just asking for more extreme behavior, it's not like they will learn from that.
He's not speaking for himself. He's voicing a huge number of people's frustration. Also, this isn't out of nowhere, it's been years in the making. Every year it gets more extreme on both sides.
I'm in SV, and it is in my best interest to prevent this, not to justify some moral high ground, as BOTH sides are doing. The evidence of who is actually correct, in my opinion, is in who can prevent the violence. If not tolerating them actually prevents it, then great, I'm probably wrong and overreacting, but I really don't see this being effective.
That's irrelevant. Your moral high ground is irrelevant once it happens. Oh well. I can't control what's going, I just know hating or ridiculing the other side won't solve anything. You are not pushing for a solution, and therefore are encouraging the conflict to reach its inevitable explosion. I don't see you or people like you as any better than them. I hope you consider this further. I can only hope for the best.
Also; note how your argument has devolved from talking about the issue, to talking about "people like (me)" - this happens often when people argue from emotion, not reason. I also never said I hated anyone - that is your (mistaken) inference, which again lends credence to the fact that this is an emotional trigger for you.
Did he? When? He had endless court battles going, he was getting shot down in state after state after state but endlessly starting new litigations.
When did we ever feel like a real transition was ever going to be allowed to happen? How many days after January 6th? How many days before January 20th? When if ever did Biden's people get allowed into the White House, when did a transition actually start if ever?
I 100% agree with parent, the rhetoric is absolutely warranted. Truth matters. What's happening has been deeply deeply anti-democratic, has been ardently fascist. Factually fascist. There's a lot of situations where we need to try to come together. A wide part of the American political spectrum has been one of snakes & liars for my entire life & truth & democracy has fallen too far down their ladder of concerns to be engagable with honestly. At this point, civilization's mandate to defend ourselves against this persistent harm is paramount. We must prioritize seeing the situation real-ly over trying to build bridges, for, so far, it seems like a radical extremist element only wants to burn every bridge they can & incite zeal & anger & violence.
Exactly. He was still following the law. You don't think an actual dictator would have been a little bit more effective at holding power? And who attempts an insurrection without guns and gives up immediately? An actual insurrection would have been a bloodbath.
I agree with your last point, we need the center to build the bridge, and start closing the gap. Failure to do so could mean we all suffer from it anyway.
people did show up with guns. those people fired them. after being told for months by their leader that a fair & democratic election was stolen from them.
the gop & trump are still making absolutely batshit claims. they still haven't allowed a peaceful transition of power. they have the stupidest most insulting long list of insane horseshit, in place after place, and it would have taken way too much of it happening in way too many places for there to have been a difference. hecs not delusional, he's continuing the role of demagogue, brining pain & division & suffering & insanity & lies to this country.
you talk about the conversation breaking down & that leading to violence & discord. one party has been driving the politics america over the cliff fory entire life. they survive only because they willfully break from reality. that is their politic. what the fuck do we do about that?
Are their concerns genuine? Are Jewish space lasers an actual concern? Are microchips really in vaccinations? Do SV companies actually have the ability to stifle their speech? Clearly he seems to be getting his message out despite them. We are at least discussing things on HN rather than threatening to shoot him.
My brother believes that the Grand Canyon was made by Noah's flood and the Earth is less than 6000 yrs old. There is no rational discussion to be had or debate to be won. We don't agree on basic facts.
I agree that mocking has not worked. The problem seems to be intensifying. From my perspective the GOP has elected representatives that do not respect compromise, policy or law. The Fat Orange Man stepped down only because he had no other options (for now). Yes - I do expect them to take it with a smile:) I expect them to return with ideas and policies that will make them win at the ballot box not threaten me with violence or take away people ability to vote.
We live in a Democracy that values the peaceful transition of power. That is why it has worked. Trump, Green and Gaetz are dangerous precisely because they do not. Nazi Germany wasn't made in a day or one speech.
I think if you don't see how it's the only remaining possibility, then you might be lacking empathy.
Imagine getting insulted by someone and when you want to verbally defend yourself, you can't because a mob of people don't let you speak. This happens again and again... what are your options in the moment? I think it would be either keep getting verbally assaulted, or try to somehow defend yourself. Now imagine that when you start giving out verbal warnings that you will physically defend yourself, the other person uses that as justification to continue the verbal assault. At that point, it's almost like both parties want to fight. One is provoking, the other is ready for it.
But I don't think it's the only reason he's saying it. The America First movement represents a style of conservatism that sees its members' social and political power at imminent risk of permanent decline due to demographic and societal changes. There's a militant dimension to this movement that frequently gives voice to the idea of a second civil war being fought against political disenfranchisement, and while Gaetz may or may not take such an idea seriously he knows that alluding to it is an easy way to get loud cheers.