Playing devil's advocate here... aren't those same two things true of Sidewalk? If you purchase an Apple tag, then you benefit from other users who have this feature enabled. If you buy a device that uses Sidewalk, same situation. Both can be disabled.
You can’t opt out of Sidewalk after June 9. You can opt out of Apple’s Find My network any time you want on a per device basis.
You can opt out at any time. June 9th is just when they're turning the network on.
Ok, I stand corrected. I interpreted as inability to opt-out after that date.
The sensationalist headlines do phrase it that way.
It's a pretty weak argument when it fits both devices. In reality both are bad, one is just very bad.