When should we consider the long-term ramifications of technological developments?
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
Technology itself is something of an exponential process. Basically, we're fuel in a kind of conflagration. If we care about the survival of our species, we need to get off this planet. Right now, we're all in the same basket. The biosphere links us all together in ways that are way too complex for a human being to comprehend. The only sensible engineering solution involves decoupling and redundancy.
Humanity hasn't had an outward frontier since the initial spread. The real frontier is technological and faces inward (Moore's law). The engineering solution is refactoring away the bloat of our bodies, when all we need is the minds. Become smaller, become faster, amplify intelligence, virtualize. This universe is cold, lifeless and slow - let's find a new universe in every atom, that's much more interesting.
</wild-speculation>
Femtotech is a dandy idea, but still speculation. We know colonizing space is technically feasible. Once we're there, we know there can be a self sustaining economy. The problem is getting there with one.
It's too easy to write this off. And you're called a nutter if you argue that anything bigger could happen soon.
And technology seems to be accelerating, but whether it is, or not, we should at least err on the side of caution, and have some formal way we integrate new things into society.
Whether it will be a force for good, or ill depends on man.
How big an error is acceptable?
It's unclear why the arguments in favor are any stronger today than they were, say, 1000 years ago. If we'd "err'd on the side of caution" then, where would we be?
What is the actual track record of folks who think that they should have a veto?
Seriously, what? Are the lawyers planning to sue the climate for changing? Are the philosophers planning to convince the planet otherwise through pure rhetoric? Non-practitioners have nothing to contribute to this discussion.
Perhaps if the geoengineering is part of a miltiary, farming or energy offering, but otherwise I doubt they will get long-term subsidy...
EDIT: add "in my opinion" to all of the above :)