How many people work in Thailand's hard drive manufacturing plants? Hundreds? Thousands? How many people in the logistics channels? How many people are vending food to these employees? How many people in the US Government? Oh, and pulling this off would also require co-ordination with Thai Government. That's hundreds of people right there.
Not if you can discredit those who dare to speak out by labeling them "conspiracy theorists," thereby discouraging others from coming out as well.
I remember an episode from an old American sitcom where people make fun of the dad (an airline pilot) when he claims to have seen a UFO. It is the same thing. Any deviation from the standard narrative isn't tolerated by most people.
Only in a technical sense.
When people talk about UFOs, they are not referring to known things like weather balloons, planes or fighter jets, but, instead, to something out of the ordinary. However, every "standard" explanation offered is one of these things.
The standard narrative here is: UFOs don't exist.
That seems like a reasonable narrative considering that the definition of UFO you used basically means "aliens".
Frankly, we don't know, and one of the reasons is, I believe, people are hesitant to take a serious look at it (or even talk about it) because they don't want to be classified as kooks.
I think the rationally correct belief is that we simply have no evidence of aliens at this time, and since we virtually know absolutely nothing about what pilots saw (all we know is that there are these observations), we just fall back to our priors (base assumptions). Sure, it might be aliens. And hence the ancient aliens meme. It might all be secret military stuff. (Or the mix of the two, hence the storm Area 51 meme.)
And in this case I don't see what's wrong with the standard narrative.
If there are truly aliens flying regularly in our atmosphere we should strap a few 4K recorders on regular airline planes, and we just have to wait.
Not to mention the increasing number of space launches and spacecraft up there. And increasing number of downward looking observatories.
While I don't know anything about the theory being discussed here, the pervasive belief in Santa Clause among children disproves your point entirely.
So unless we all are living in a very well orchestrated NSA Truman show, it's unlikely that your argument applies.
"All right," said Susan. "I'm not stupid. You're saying humans need... fantasies to make life bearable."
REALLY? AS IF IT WAS SOME KIND OF PINK PILL? NO. HUMANS NEED FANTASY TO BE HUMAN. TO BE THE PLACE WHERE THE FALLING ANGEL MEETS THE RISING APE.
"Tooth fairies? Hogfathers? Little—"
YES. AS PRACTICE. YOU HAVE TO START OUT LEARNING TO BELIEVE THE LITTLE LIES.
"So we can believe the big ones?"
YES. JUSTICE. MERCY. DUTY. THAT SORT OF THING.
"They're not the same at all!"
YOU THINK SO? THEN TAKE THE UNIVERSE AND GRIND IT DOWN TO THE FINEST POWDER AND SIEVE IT THROUGH THE FINEST SIEVE AND THEN SHOW ME ONE ATOM OF JUSTICE, ONE MOLECULE OF MERCY. AND YET—Death waved a hand. AND YET YOU ACT AS IF THERE IS SOME IDEAL ORDER IN THE WORLD, AS IF THERE IS SOME...SOME RIGHTNESS IN THE UNIVERSE BY WHICH IT MAY BE JUDGED.
"Yes, but people have got to believe that, or what's the point—"
MY POINT EXACTLY -Hogfather
For a TL:DR of Making Money, there's
https://www.ft.com/content/1aebc9f8-70bb-11dc-98fc-0000779fd...
I'd still recommend the book though. There are so many things that are little more than flaky veneers taken for granted in adult human life that the fact anything works at all generally comes down to an intentioned group of people 'conspiring' to make it so, and no one ever bothers to ask about it, as it 'just werkz' and creates value. It's only a problem when too many externalities get ignored, in which case, everyone starts to notice.
Once you understand this, the beauty of the 'conspiracy theorist' meme coming out of an intelligence agency to get people to stop taking those who ask inconvenient questions starts to take on a stroke of genius. You get people who rock the boat discredited out the gate, and reinforce the status quo.
...Until that document gets declassified and blows up in your face anyway.
That would be similar to the way in which the fake Swiss cryptographic machine manufacturer was run. Their only leak risks were from employees who realized that their cryptosystem was easily broken. An HDD manufacturer would not have that problem because all of its work would be perfectly legitimate.
If everything in the world were an illusion, I doubt that any group would be able to orchestrate that for all of us. But large groups can coordinate secret happenings, and they do, all the time.
No, it proves it.
Default hypothesis: Santa is real.
For Santa to be a conspiracy: my parents and all my friends’ parents must be lying to their children.
Therefore: Santa is believed.
Just because a customer orders a few gazillion of product x and wants to keep it quiet doesn’t make some kind of nutty conspiracy theory. It happens all the time. The Thailand floods drew down production even more, but without the giant order, there wouldn’t have been the same impact.
Fun fact, any time two or more people want to keep something on the DL , it’s a conspiracy. Nearly everything that an intelligence agency does, is de facto, a conspiracy.
That seems... totally expected? The problem comes when you're trying to use it as proof of something. Some conspiracy theories do turn out to be true, but that doesn't mean every conspiracy is true.
Companies are uniquely positioned to minimise risk in their ability to execute.
I remember this period well and aware that a number of large players basically bought up whatever supply was available to cover their needs in the short to medium term. The result was that retail pricing more or less doubled (if you could even get drives).
So, just for the fun of it: Forbes estimates a capacity (at the time) of up to 12 EB [1]. Assuming they used 3TB drives, they'd need 4 million drives for this [2]. This article [3] shows the market for consumer drives at about 150 million in 2013 (figure 7). So the NSA order would've been in the ballpark of 2% of consumer drives sales - insanely large at the face of it, yes, but probably not enough to cause such a shortage.
[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2013/07/24/blueprin...
[2] https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=12%20exabytes%20%2F%20...
[3] https://www.forbes.com/sites/tomcoughlin/2020/05/29/hdd-mark...
I know of people who were delivering software to certain customers that were required/intended to work on EB scale datasets over a decade ago, and this was well before the Utah data center was a thing.
There's all kinds of things to think about like how 2% may be less than 100% but in an elastic supply of a globally distributed good, 2% of (total yearly) supply called upon all at once can be a _huge_ departure from the norm. Maybe the shortage isn't just a hard disk shortage but a shortage of shipping space to take those hard drives anywhere else but to the NSA. Maybe it's that the factory(s) don't make 100% of the drives in an instant and then just distribute them for the rest of the year, but slowly make a constant stream of drives, all of which were swallowed up for a period of time by the massive order, causing the shortage.
There's a million other factors besides just "this number smaller that this number".
It looks like you've picked only the most favorable statistics and ignored everything else in formulating your opinion/response.
I really have no feelings for this theory either way, I simply don't think it's realistic.
> There's all kinds of things to think about like how 2% may be less than 100% but in an elastic supply of a globally distributed good, 2% of (total yearly) supply called upon all at once can be a _huge_ departure from the norm.
I generally agree with that. However, for one, we're talking about consumer goods within a growing marked - a demand jump of 2% should be within expected deviation and not generate the problems we've seen there.
> Maybe the shortage isn't just a hard disk shortage but a shortage of shipping space to take those hard drives anywhere else but to the NSA.
3,5" hard drives have a volume of ~ 390.000 mm^3. Let's say that's 3.000.000 mm^3 shipped. That would allow ~10.854 drives in a standard container, for a total of 370 (assuming 4 million drives). A large container ship can pack 850,000 containers. So yes, it's a large volume, but for global shipping it's a drop in the bucket.
> Maybe it's that the factory(s) don't make 100% of the drives in an instant and then just distribute them for the rest of the year, but slowly make a constant stream of drives, all of which were swallowed up for a period of time by the massive order, causing the shortage.
Sure they do. But, again: If we're assuming 2% of total drives, it would be the output for one week. Not ideal, but not a major shortage. And that's the worst-case scenario: Orders in the billions of dollars don't usually work in the time frame of one week; it's quite likely that the manufacturers knew of this well in advance and were able to upscale/order accordingly.
> Out of 150 million drives, there might not have been 4 million 3TB drives out there, this was 2014, maybe there was but they didn't want all the exact same drive, if you calculate that some of the drives are 2TB or 1TB the estimated numbers only get larger.
Sure. But 4TB drives and probably 6TB were also available at the time and it's reasonable that for extremely large storage, they'd shoot for larger drives - if only for space and heat efficiency. There surely were a few smaller drives as cache etc. here and there, but I'd presume the lions share to be large drives.
> I think it's totally reasonable that a single order of 12,000,000TB to a single location in Utah could grind the widespread consumer market to a halt for a bit,
I won't disagree with that it surely did impact the market a bit, but I highly doubt it was a major cause for the shortage. Especially when there's a perfectly fine explanation of a tsunami hitting where most drives are manufactured.
> especially if they're almost all made in one place, which it seems most of this discussion is taking for granted.
Most likely they'd order from multiple manufacturers, alone for capacity and failure probability reasons. In fact, if they actually ordered in one place, you could easily get evidence for this theory by showing the problems originating from one specific manufacturer.
> It looks like you've picked only the most favorable statistics and ignored everything else in formulating your opinion/response.
I highly disagree with that. I picked the largest estimate of the data center size and the capacity commonly available to consumers at the time; additionally, I only used a (low!) estimate for the size of the consumer market and completely disregarded the enterprise one. If anything, I probably overestimated the impact.
A said above, the massive buying surely did not help the shortage and I dislike the NSA as much as the next guy. But unless my estimation is off by an order of magnitude the numbers simply don't add up - even assuming the ordered with a delivery date of yesterday! - and given that there's a very reasonable alternative explanation for the shortage, I don't think this is a sound theory.
So is there any 'open secret in the industry' about the current chip shortage, that I'm unaware of?
If something is not indexed by Google, it's effectively non-existent. FAANG censorship is fast and effective. E.g. there were many important US bureaucrats involved in the Theranos scandal (even current US president). When I try to find anything related to that matter now, Google returns pages with many links removed by censors. It's almost impossible to find people responsible for withdrawing money from US budget via Theranos.
Also, assuming that 3 letter agencies were involved in the operation, any whistleblower would understand that destiny of Epstein will await her/him in near future.
Also, there's no "independent" journalism, all media belong to few influential entities, there's only approved articles appear in newspapers, magazines, on TV and YouTube.
If someone posted a plausible/verifiable account of what happened in a HN thread, then it would've made it halfway round the world before the NSA could take it down
So why didn't they bother censoring this comment?
Where did this idea come from?
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
One thing I learned recently, which made the effect of the 2011 flood on the HD market worst: Aramco purchased a big chunk of several months of the world supply of hard drive to recover from Shamoon in 2012, by replacing every HD in the company [1]
(Wikipedia page on the facility in question: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utah_Data_Center)
Nobody is alleging that but you. Personally I don't think either "surveillance system needs a way to store what is collected" or "high-volume customers have economic leverage to demand confidentiality" are particularly intricate concepts.
To claim that the NSA took advantage of an existing event to help their already-planned ordering fly under the radar more easily is perfectly plausible. And, honestly, pretty boring.
Which one are you alleging? Choosing your words carefully might be wise.
https://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=2118801&itype=CMSI...
https://archive.thinkprogress.org/nsa-tries-to-keep-its-wate...
Are you saying that there either was no tsunami or that the NSA created the tsunami as a cover to buy harddrives?
Why not just start a rumour claiming the price is increasing due to huge demand?