Jeff Geerling's work on Raspberry Pi modules and extension boards found out its not possible at least on the PI4:
From https://www.jeffgeerling.com/blog/2020/external-gpus-and-ras...
"... so far, the answer seems to be 'no.'
Partly it's due to lack of support for I/O BAR space on the BCM2711 ARM SoC, and partly it may be due to driver bugs or features that are only supported on X86 or certain ARM architectures."
So I wonder when people like Marcan say the hardware is there do they mean that the M1 doesn't have such I/O limitations?
I know Tallos Blackbird POWER9 boards can work with discrete GPUs. I don't know if they are making use but I imagine amdgpu kernel module should work just as fine on a different arch.
> just a "if they were planning on doing it any time soon, they'd have announced it by now" situation?
Yes that's the case.