I also find the logic at paragraph 17 somewhat strange:
> The parties were required to contact Juracek to obtain high resolution digital files as the CD-ROM files were not high resolution. For the sake of clarity, anyone seeking a license for the photographs from the book or CD-ROM were required to contact Plaintiff to obtain the photos in a high resolution digital file suitable for commercial use as all rights were reserved as set forth in the copyright notice.
What if you don't need high-resolution images for your particular use? Noting that they had to contact the author to obtain higher resolution images seems irrelevant when determining if they had a licence to use the images present on the CD (unless it's alleged they used the higher resolution images and must have obtained them from another source, which I don't believe is the case).
That's not what I was trying to say. What I meant that the claimant's argument is simply "You did not have a licence to use the images on the CD in that way". Presenting the argument as "the parties were required to contact Juracek to obtain high resolution digital files [and they did not do so]" _seems_ to add a particular significance to the high resolution images, when it's, as you say, irrelevant (what matters is whether they obtained a licence, not the high resolution images). Unless I'm missing something, you could replace paragraph 17 with:
> As a result of the book and photographs and CD-ROM, Juracek licensed copies of various photographs to many different parties who sought to use the photos commercially and the book became a very popular way for architects and designers to obtain exclusive high quality examples of unique decorative surfaces and features. Anyone seeking a license for the photographs from the book or CD-ROM were required to contact Plaintiff to obtain a commercial use license as all rights were reserved as set forth in the copyright notice.
and have the same effect. It just seemed like a needlessly complicated way to make the same argument.
There are some specific contemplated and limited uses in the blurb/text. It's not clear to me how those play against the plain fact of the copyright, but I doubt that claiming an author needs to repeatedly claim copyright for it be valid is going to get far.