I feel like you’re being way too harsh on the people who buy gold and silver. The fact is both of those commodities do tend to hold onto their value very well over long stretches of time. Sure, investing in an index fund would have yielded more money but we only know that in hindsight. It’s not universally true that the stock market gets people the best returns. The fact is that gold and silver, while dumb and simple elements, will last longer than any company or government will. And there is some value in that. I don’t fault risk averse people for investing in scarce resources.