The US has little interest in hitting home companies in any way. Preventing the false advertising would impact the value of Tesla because the FSD claims were an integral part of Tesla's branding and success. Some countries in Europa, like Germany, blocked Tesla from using misleading claims in their advertising like suggesting anything about self driving [1]. Of course this is usually dismissed as Germany protecting its auto industry. But the reality is that the claims Tesla made consistently misleading and made to suggest the cars is able to self-drive and it's only regulations that prevent it from doing this.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/General_Motors_ignition_switch...
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/14/business/tesla-autopilot-...
Tesla has no reason to crash and burn but without a real or perceived edge over the competition it wouldn't thrive. And the self driving claim is a hefty part of that edge.
Tesla not only got "infinite" marketing and PR points by claiming "FSD", they even got money from people who are still waiting for that functionality. Those who expected driver assists are happy. Those who expected the claimed FSD are certainly not.
Today with competing companies like Volvo announcing L4 cars in 2022, the generic FSD claims are nowhere nearly as valuable as a few years ago.
Reminds me of Wirecard, which imploded one year ago. Everyone, from regulation agencies over banks to politics - including Chancellor Merkel and her advisors - wanted Wirecard to succeed at all costs. In the latest hours of Wirecard, after the "we're missing two billion euros" statement, there even was the idea to pump hundreds of millions of euros taxpayer money to prevent its collapse.
But Tesla and Wirecard are in no way in the same league. Tesla is actually delivering cars, batteries, building factories, and developing tech. Wirecard on the other hand was a hot air balloon, at least after a point.
People are easily thrown off by the fact that Tesla is successfully delivering a physical product and that the product is excellent in many aspects (driving UX, charger network, software integration, EV evangelism etc).
However once you look closer, a whole host of parallels emerge: 'Very aggressive accounting' (non-GAAP, 20% accounts receivables, junior CFO, warranty repairs as goodwill etc), business is not profitable (revenues stem from tax credits not cars), bail out/enrichment of Musk family (SolarCity), securities fraud (funding secured), retaliation against whistleblowers, silencing/threatening critics and journalists, legal record, occupational health violations (injured workers not being treated, Covid), workers at the factories not being allowed to speak to visitors, selling something that doesn't exist (FSD), environmental concerns at Fremont, ...
It's a different business than Wirecard for sure, and only time will tell, but the red flags are all there.
Unfortunately, these issues - while perfectly legitimate to name them! - are extremely common throughout the entire US corporate and government culture. Exploitation of all kinds is pervasive.
Well... yes, simply because hindsight usually provides evidence while foresight provides guidance. So while I agree with your points, and as much as I dislike Musk (a criminal who's crimes are overlooked because of his status), your case pivots on the assumption that they're certainly faking it, just weren't caught yet. And you could be right. But so could Scientology.
The fact that Tesla is delivering what we can easily verify with our eyes at the very least puts them in a vastly different league from Wirecard. Tesla could be a unprofitable business like so many others. But Wirecard wasn't just a failing business, it was massive scale fraud and nothing it left behind still proves useful and can provide value now.
The liquidation price was nowhere near its market value and their technology was nowhere near as innovative - both points that are also true for Tesla.
Again, don't be led astray by the fact that Tesla is making physical products that you can see.
On a different note I don't think of corporate fraud as something that brings you from 0 to 1 - it's more akin to cheating in sports. It will give you a competitive edge, an unfair advantage.
If you are interested there is an interview with the CFO of Enron about legal fraud on Youtube - highly fascinating.