Fixed voltage drop on an LED is too much of a simplification for this application. A better mental model is to imagine a piecewise linear approximation of current–voltage characteristic aka I–V curve.
I-V curve of a resistor is a straight line that goes through (0,0) point, with slope inversely proportional to resistance. The curve for LED has a bend somewhere between 1.5V and 2V, where its slope changes from low to high.