Essentially, what we are witnessing is the transfer of responsibility for public goods and services from democratic institutions to the wealthy, to be administered by an executive class. In the CEO society, the exercise of social responsibilities is no longer debated in terms of whether corporations should or shouldn’t be responsible for more than their own business interests. Instead, it is about how philanthropy can be used to reinforce a politico-economic system that enables such a small number of people to accumulate obscene amounts of wealth. Zuckerberg’s investment in solutions to the Bay Area housing crisis is an example of this broader trend." [1]
Although with your "in excruciating detail" it sounds like you've been presented with the evidence before, yet you are somehow unwilling to admit the failings of the system. This last part is meant as an observation and not as a negative value judgement.
This video with Anand Giridharadas is also great: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d_zt3kGW1NM, as well as his book 'Winners Take All: The Elite Charade of Changing the World'.
[1] https://www.theguardian.com/news/2018/may/24/the-trouble-wit...
Given that he's stepping down as CEO this year, the difference between a $10B deduction on his taxes this year and the same amount of money deducted across multiple future years when he has less income can be substantial.
(This argument assumes that he intends to spend $10B on charitable donations at some point in his life anyway; it's not an argument for why spending $10B is better for his taxes than not spending it at all.)
For carries of founder stock who have zero cost basis for their stock this can allow you to actually make more money depending on current interest rates.
Is this a way of getting a different tax rate?
But all of these things really only grant you more utility than just paying the taxes if you get (non-economic) utility out of the donation or (non-economic) utility out of the feeling of paying less taxes. Of course, you could get economic utility out of the donation, but that is likely to be less than legal.
OTOH, I could see a possible way to make donating apprechiated assets work out to have economic utility. If the tax rates are high enough, and assuming zero cost basis and high ordinary income, you avoid X * Y% tax by donating, and you reduce tax on other income by X * Z%, where X is your donation, Y% is your total (marginal) capital gains tax rate, and Z% is your total ordinary income tax rate. If Y + Z is greater than 100%, that's a real savings.
IIRC, top federal capital gains rate is 20 + 3.8 (net investment income tax), and if you live in california, 13.3 state tax = 37.1%
Top federal ordinary income is 37%, if in california that ends up with 50.3% tax rate.
Adding those up we get 87.4%, so a donation of apprechiated assets with zero basis doesn't quite create value, but it's close. Maybe some other state has a higher top tax rate.
So long as the marginal tax rate is <100%, you will always lose more money by giving it away than by keeping it and paying tax on it.