Hacker News Reader

Comment by reducesuffering | Hacker News Reader

Have you forgotten why a US military was necessary just 75 years ago to save the UK from destruction?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Sea_Lion

Check your timeline. The US wasn’t even in the war then. Though American help was instrumental later in the war, the UK actually saved itself from invasion (with help from fellow Commonwealth nations). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Britain

My point was not about US involvement in a specific battle but that of Nazi Germany's clear intent to invade the UK, likely only eventually abated by US involvement.

Like you said, the UK saved itself (for now), but "American help was instrumental later."

After the Battle of Britain ended, and Operation Barbarossa started, it was impossible for Germany to invade the UK. That was 6 months before the US entered the war.

I get the point you're making, but American military involvement had almost nothing to do with the UK repelling German invasion specifically.

Not specifically. Imagine the war without US involvement. No more Western and Eastern front. Germany still wouldn't have captured Moscow but they would have secured large swaths of eastern territory and thus economic might. They would've had stable control over most of Europe and been further bolstered economically and militarily to eventually take the UK.

>No more Western and Eastern front. Germany still wouldn't have captured Moscow but they would have secured large swaths of eastern territory

I don't understand, in your made-up hypothetical, is there an Eastern Front or not? Or, are you mis-using "Eastern Front" to refer to the war with Japan perhaps?

As soon as Germany lost the Battle of Britain and then failed to immediately take Russia, their fate was sealed. The war was lost, period.

The next question was - would Russia overrun all of Europe (including Western Europe)? Without US involvement, that may have actually happened. Thankfully, it did not.

Terrible choice of battle, One that the UK won handily of its own ingenuity and cunning as stated in the wikipedia.

My point was not about US involvement in a specific battle but that of Nazi Germany's clear intent to invade the UK, likely only eventually abated by US involvement.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com