So... why not with CPUs?
So... why not with CPUs?
The remedy for an entire industry's product performing to a degree less than advertised is a class action lawsuit (good luck getting more than about five dollars for something like this), not returning the products for a refund.
As someone said below (maybe after you posted)
> Then with that money I can do whatever I want... eg. buy an AMD washing machine... or generally a newer, faster one, becuase some time has gone by. Or go on a vacation. Or drugs and prostitutes.
The other options here are "Well, I'll just not have a washing machine". Which you can do, but it will take more time to clean your clothes and cost more money after not very many washes at all (or you hand-wash, but then you're looking at 10x as long). Same for computers -- if simply not having one is an option for you, you probably haven't noticed the degradation.
They should give you your money back, or replace the CPU with one that is as fast as your old one before they crippled it - ie. new CPU with eg. higher clock to compensate for the speed loss due to this fix.
If you buy a 1000lumen lightbulb, and the manufacturer has to lower the output by 50% because of overheating, they should either give me my money back, or give me a 2000lumen bulb which was crippled to 1000lumen, to get the original brightness i bought the bulb for.
One thing you might say is that this change happened even to lightbulbs I've had for 5+ years. I can buy a functional 1000lm bulb for the same price now, due to the march of technology! The problem is that I've been using the lightbulb for five years already. If you use a lightbulb for five years, and then it fails entirely, the manufacturer is never going to give you a full refund: why would they give you a full refund for a lesser failure mode?
The choice is not between silently letting manufacturers cripple stuff, and having non-crippled stuff. The choice is between silently letting manufacturers cripple stuff, and loudly letting manufacturers cripple stuff. You're welcome to do the latter, but your stuff is still going to be crippled.
- keep the old "firmware", and risk the machine catching fire
- put the new firmware on, and make it wash slower
Yeah... I'll choose returning it to the store.
Or perhaps more accurately, someone spoiling your clothes by putting a dye in their pocket and letting you wash it in the same batch.
The problem isn't that they made the patch, it's that they made a defective part in the first place. The patch just fails to cure the fact that they made a defective part.
The problem, IMO, is that a manufacturer of a high-quality washing machine has the human ability to go through and engineer out or (or economize in) every conceivable failure mode. There's no need to issue updates, because it only does the specific behaviors that it was designed to do. Each part has a wear characteristic, can corrode, can be mechanically stressed...but a pressed sheet metal bracket is fundamentally always going to be a bracket, either it corrodes, or wears, or yields, or it doesn't, or else it holds the things it's supposed to hold, there's just not that many ways in which the performance of a bracket can surprise the designer. The owner's manual says it's to be transported carefully, installed on a flat surface indoors, plumbed to water/wired to 120VAC/drained through a standpipe, and then you operate it by adding clothes and turning the knob. It's a fixed-purpose washing machine, that's what it does.
In contrast, Intel employed very smart, hardworking designers to write the microcode and HDL that describe the `vmovdqu YMMWORD PTR [rax], ymm1` assembly instruction, they thought about what that meant, what side effects it could have, why it should do what it does, and they probably were quite pleased when they optimized it to be faster when doing zero stores. But while the hypothetical ME for our washing machine could probably comprehend every requirement for the bracket, the Intel designers didn't build a fixed-purpose machine, they built a general-purpose machine that runs both trusted and untrusted code of unknown, highly flexible contents. The state machine describing all possible results of a Turing complete processor even with storage limited to mere gigabytes instead of an infinite tape, is unimaginably large. I maintain that numbers over a few thousand are humanly impossible to fully imagine, but to put it in concrete terms, worldwide, literally every second on the order of 10^20 novel combinations of 64 bit instructions are executed by a CPU, and every second, millions of programmers and computer users are generating never-before-seen demands of the hardwrae.
It's impossible to predict every side effect of every combination of instructions a CPU will run. Meanwhile, the brackets are simple brackets, handing the same requirements and performing the same functions that the designer should have known about when they designed it.
What CPU are you replacing it with? Most if not all modern CPUs are vulnerable to this so changing it makes little sense. Even if you can change it, you'd need to switch motherboard as well.
Then with that money I can do whatever I want... eg. buy an AMD washing machine... or generally a newer, faster one, becuase some time has gone by. Or go on a vacation. Or drugs and prostitutes.
We wouldn't accept that on any generic customer product. We'd recall whole fleet of cars if they had severe flaws that directly affect their performance.
There might not be viable alternatives, but there should be at least something from CPU makers to help swallow the pill.
No one gave you a guarantee that “there will never be any security issues with this product and if there are, mitigations will cause no performance degradation”.
If you want that promise you’re gonna have to pay for it, man. And it’s not gonna be a flat fee. That’s an insurance model.
We expect that this issue will be sorted out soon.
In the meantime we hope you'll consider that speed and security are sometimes traded off, in this world of network-aware, gigahertz speed washing machines which you can also use to do banking, create spreadsheets and watch your favorite movies.