Surreal numbers (2014)
ianopolous.peergos.me
ianopolous.peergos.me
Surreal Numbers – An Introduction (2019) [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27351926 - June 2021 (73 comments)
Donald Knuth: Surreal Numbers [video] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11987415 - June 2016 (54 comments)
I thought there were others! Maybe someone will find some.
Surreal Numbers (cut-the-knot.org) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3734829 - March 2012 (0 comments)
Is this true? They talk about surreals defined on day aleph-null. Is there a day for every possible cardinal? What about large cardinals?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_large_cardinal_propert...
Each ordinal appears at the day with its number; e.g., omega (first infinite ordinal, kinda corresponds to aleph-zero) appears on day omega, 2^omega appears on day 2^omega, etc., etc. There is a day for each ordinal.
There are whatever large cardinals the underlying set theory has. (Though Conway took the view that rather than building the apparatus of surreal numbers on top of a particular set theory like ZFC, you should think of this as its own theory that resembles set theory but has two different kinds of "set membership" (left and right) and someone should prove a theorem saying that such things are always at least as consistent as ZFC...)
I don't think large cardinals play any particular role in the theory of surreal numbers, games, etc.
2^omega = omega [0]
Did you meant to say that omega_1 (the smallest uncountable ordinal number [1]) appears on day aleph_1 (which is the same as day 2^aleph_0 = beth_1 if we assume CH)
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordinal_arithmetic#Exponentiat...
(But I definitely didn't mean to say that anything appears "on day aleph-1"; day numbers are ordinals.)
Of course, I then goofed, so maybe now you think I am a bit fuzzy on the difference between ordinals and cardinals :-).
So, to be quite precise, and hopefully correct all errors and apparent errors so far:
If you construct the surreals "day by day" then each ordinal alpha is born on day alpha. Every ordinal appears; no two ordinals are equal. Cardinals play no special role in the surreal numbers, so far as I am aware. There are whatever large cardinals there are in the underlying set theory; these too play no particular role in the surreal numbers, so far as I am aware. (Though I assume that e.g. inaccessible cardinals give you set models of the surreal numbers, just as they give you set models of ZFC.) It is true that 2^omega appears on day 2^omega but since 2^omega=omega this is just the same as saying that omega appears on day omega.