Desert plants are struggling in higher heat
scientificamerican.com
scientificamerican.com
Since then, 100-plus-degree days have been happening more and more regularly. We're adding a second AC unit because there have been days that the first one just can't keep up. All this in 11 years.
This keeps me up at night too:
https://www.cnn.com/2021/06/17/us/earth-trapped-heat-doubled...
There was a time when I was fairly sure that climate change would lead to the collapse of civilization, but there was no way I'd live to see it. Now I'm not so sure about the latter.
[UPDATE] There is also the sobering realization that even if we brought carbon emissions to zero tomorrow (which is obviously not going to happen) even that would not actually solve the problem. We're at 50% over pre-industrial CO2 with no viable way of getting rid of it, so at best it's going to stay that way for a long, long time.
I would like nothing more than for you to be right about this. But I don't think you are. We're at 420PPM CO2 right now. Even if we cut CO2 emissions to zero and eliminated all methane emissions, we'd still be retaining heat at a rate that is more than enough to produce a blue-ocean event [1] in the next decade or two, after which we're probably screwed.
[1] https://glennfay.medium.com/the-blue-ocean-event-will-be-a-t...
And whether it will even be possible by then to remove enough carbon to make a difference. It's far from clear that it's even possible now. It took several hundred million years for nature to sequester all that carbon in the first place. It has taken us a mere 300 years to release it, but releasing carbon is one hell of a lot easier than sequestering it. And we're staring down the barrel of a blue ocean event in the next few decades, possibly even the next few years.
We have multiple viable tools. Oviline, some kind of atmospheric dimming, rewilding, industrial carbon capture. And I'm sure we'll try 100s of other ideas and strategies.
My current grumpiness is that we're not already dual track.
Yes, we have to get humanity to carbon zero. Urgently.
We also need to remove carbon. By whatever means possible.
We just can't wait for carbon zero before we start carbon negative efforts.
--
I haven't heard or seen any efforts about securing current carbon sinks. Like maybe replant the tundras with stuff that will delay the thawing. Or precapturing submerged methane and flaring it. Or...?
It might be technologically possible. But right now the limiting factor is people's complacency. Only a very tiny minority seems to be taking the problem as seriously as it should be taken. Everyone still seems to think that we're looking at the odd anomalous heat wave here and there, and that real catastrophe is still several generations away. It isn't. The first thing that needs to change is for everyone, and our political leaders in particular, to accept that. Because by the time it becomes obvious to everyone that we have been staring down the barrel of a gun for the last 300 years it really will be too late.
What's the alternative?
I volunteered for Audubon's Wetlands Conservation Network effort for a decade. Trying to save the wild salmon, maybe even restore some.
I learned from them in the early 90s that it was already game over. (Confirmed at the time by my physicist cousin who pivoted his career to work on climate crisis.) I asked the biologists (my bosses) how they managed to persevere, knowing what they know. They answered that they just focus on the work, and try to enjoy life outside of work.
So I came to think of it as Pascal's Wager for the survival of civilization, humanity itself, and very probably most of life.
We probably won't survive. But why not try?
Not telling you anything you don't know.
Policy change happens very slowly, then all at once. So who knows? Maybe we'll out run the bear.
If and when we pull our thumbs out, assuming I'm still here, I intend to help however I can. At the very least, working on something important would be nice.
I've been reading your posts for a while now. I'm sure you'll help too.
Peace.
Wow. Climate change wasn't even on most people's radar then.
One of his salient points IIRC was when you're living through an exponential curve that's approaching some crisis threshold, be it population growth leading to civilization collapse, or some resource consumption exhausting its supply, it happens very abruptly because you jump from just halfway to the end, which through a linear lens appears very distant, to at the critical end, in just a single doubling period.
Even if climate change significantly affects our lives, why would it cause civilization to collapse? It seems just as plausible that adverse conditions will increase the necessity of civilization, of strong social bonds and mutal reliance.
It's very interesting to me that, when talking about climate change, we tend to assume everything is negative. Surely there are some upsides (the only one I ever hear about is Arctic shipping routes). But I think we have no good reason to be making claims like "civilization will collapse". This seems like millenarian thinking, people like the idea of living in the end times.
I would not bet on this bringing people together, unless it’s the very well off (“the haves”) against those without who will be exposed to more suffering.
But there's no point in arguing about it. When we all die and civilization hasn't collapsed, we'll all know I'm right.
When you're on your deathbed and civilization hasn't collapsed, I wonder if you'll think of this thread.
If, 10-20 years from now, there are world-wide food riots because of global crop failures and the entire western US is burning in one gigantic continent-wide forest fire, will you?
I'll tell you what, I'll ask my dad if he remembers the first person in the 1970s who told him the world was going to end in ten years due to global cooling
I remember in the 90s it was the ozone hole that was going to cause us all to burn
When everything is relatively fine -- climate will change, of course, as it always has, and humans will adapt -- I won't think of you, or this thread, because why would I waste my time?
But I'll remember all the fearmongers and doomsayers and chicken littles, more generally
Every generation has them
Read this and calm down https://m.barnesandnoble.com/w/apocalypse-never-michael-shel...
But that's the thing: it hasn't always. For the last 10,000 years the climate has been relatively stable, and that is the reason that human civilization was able to emerge in the first place. It's hard to build cities if the arable land moves every 10 years.
Yes, every age has its doomsayers. But this time it really is different.
It's much worse than this. For a long time the "worst case scenario" was the possibility that we'd unlock positive feedback loops that release methane (80x as "warming" as CO2) that had been long locked in arctic permafrost.
Remember the phrase "runaway climate change"?
Yeah. It happened. Even if bring human carbon emissions to zero, the world will continue to warm.
This is why of the utmost importance to stop fossil fuel emissions NOW... so we can win ourselves some time to maybe, just maybe, figure out clean carbon removal.
I'm not so sure.
One thing Trump got absolutely right (intentionally or not) was borrowing money when interest rates are low. There's really no reason not to. If we spend $10T kick starting a carbon capture industry, at near zero interest rates, surely those enterprises will at least break even.
Even Big Oil would want some of that sweet, juicy pork.
u/elbasti is referring to the now active positive feedback loops as separate additional sources GHG and warming.
Apologies if that's the distinction you were trying to make.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/may/30/canada-inuits-...
[1] https://www.livescience.com/4180-sahara-desert-lush-populate...
Edit-Also be polite. No death threats…
I was modeling my thoughts on the hundreds of thousands of Net Neutrality comments that were received by the FCC a few years ago. That they doctored the perception (using bots) that the proportion of submissions against upholding net neutrality was higher than it really was is another story..
Carbon footprint reduction is inevitable. Your choice, Mr. Congressman, is whether it will be smaller shoes or fewer feet.
Instigating panic, fear, dread and a host of other human responses, by "agitating" .. is a physical option and really courts disasters of all kinds.
On the other hand, many thousands of reports generated in the last two decades, is also apparently not enough either.
Alert! Aware! .. and encourage, analyze, communicate.
People can very clearly see the system is falling to bits, but I'm not sure most people understand it's actually a group of interconnected systems. I mean, they know, but I don't believe it's easy for people to wrap a mental model around all this. I also think there are still very many people who believe it will not affect them meaningfully within their lifetime.
I bet a lot of people would like to help for free. Most of us feel helpless most of the time.
I do remember seeing them all the time 20 years ago.
It's just that some of them don't believe it, and were voted in by supporters who don't believe it. They aren't going to turn around to their constituents and say "huh, turns out climate change is real and bad, so I'm going to do the opposite of what I promised when you voted for me." No amount of scholarship will ever change that.
As for what will... search me. It seems to be self-reinforcing at this point. Maybe the steady drumbeat of articles like this will help change the minds of ordinary people, though I can't see how.
Isn't it like a known thing that photosynthesis stops happening at higher temperatures? I've been worried about the impact of days-over-100-degrees on crop production for years.
Is "unexpected" in this headline standing in for "now demonstrated in the wild, counter-intuitive if you don't know that biology is highly sensitive to temperature, expected by people in the field", or if I knew more about desert plant biology, would I be more shocked than I am now?
The meat of it appears to be the following: Satellite photos show decline in vegetative cover in the Sonoran desert between 1984 and 2017.
Therefore" `Dryland ecosystems "may be more susceptible to climate change than expected,"`
Has the temperature of the Sonoran desert changed significantly enough in that period of time to explain this decreased vegetation? Doubtful. How about rainfall? Maybe, likely not.
So what has changed in the Sonoran desert in the last 30 years? One thing right off the bat, a massive influx of people as the Phoenix/Tucson areas have grown tremendously.
Maybe that is something to look at? Is there more human activity (for example ATVs) in these fragile habitats? More air pollution (yes there is that). More of something else?
To really show warming was causing this decrease in vegetation they would need to show a mechanism that caused it to occur. And quantify it. i.e "Palo Verde trees die when the average nighttime temperature is above XX or annual rainfall is below YY". But nope, they don't do that.
This approach works well for oceans... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marine_cloud_brightening
I suppose that we might start treating the earth like a garden we need to take care of?
ψ