Apple claims they did it because the runtime estimate wasn't accurate enough. Maybe Microsoft's reason was the same. Though it does seem user hostile to remove it, unless the estimate was substantially off and there's no way to fix it.
Apple claims they did it because the runtime estimate wasn't accurate enough. Maybe Microsoft's reason was the same. Though it does seem user hostile to remove it, unless the estimate was substantially off and there's no way to fix it.
I think the problem is that users expect percent charge to be a direct, linear correlate of time remaining, but battery discharge isn't linear. Even if it were, predicting time left is tough. Giving the user a percentage rather than a (likely incorrect) time estimate seems like the less bad approach.
It seems like it would be trivial to change the default and leave the time estimate as an option.
Personally I don't use Windows on any of my laptops, so I only noticed this one day on my work laptop. On my Linux laptops my status bar is literally just doing a weighted average of "time_remaining = energy_remaining / current_power", which works rather nicely.
That a supposedly top-notch software company like Microsoft is trying to gaslight their users into "predicting battery life is like hard you know! We're gonna remove it because it's so inaccurate, it's basically unsolvable aha" makes me throw up a little, but is also such an accurate and damning reflection of the way these companies conduct themselves.
Apple responding by hiding the estimate—even on their older computers, where it worked very well—struck me as utterly missing the point.