Which history is that?
Genuine question - I'm aware of places where speech is suppressed because the justice system is not independent of the political system.
I'm aware of cases where speech is suppressed by the threat of being sued by private individuals.
But where are the cases where hate-speech carve-outs have been abused in democracies?
>In the US, a large number of anti-BDS laws have been passed. As of 2020, 32 states have laws that prevent boycotts against Israel and a number of non-binding resolutions have been passed denouncing BDS. A majority of these have passed with strong bipartisan support. Two federal acts have been introduced, the 2017 Israel Anti-Boycott Act and the 2019 Combating BDS Act, both intended to deprive entities participating in boycotts of Israel of government contract work. In several states, these laws have been challenged on First Amendment grounds for violating citizens' freedom of speech.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boycott,_Divestment_and_Sancti...
[1]: https://theintercept.com/2017/08/29/in-europe-hate-speech-la...
For instance the ruling against activists boycotting Israel was based on them focusing on a whole country (with kind words like “Israel murderer”) which by definition will englobe unrelated individuals, in a shop targeted at the diaspora.
Think about how it would look if today we had “fuck off China” protests in the middle of Chinatown.
If pro-Uighur activists wore t-shirts that said "long live Xinjiang, boycott China" in Chinatown, do you think they ought to be charged with a crime? Frankly, I find that idea appalling, and I find the conviction of those pro-Palestine activists appalling too.
They did a tad more than that, enough to each get 1000 euros fines. Also it’s not like they’re now in concentration camps, they just got a slap on the hand.
The whole ruling if you care: https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/juri/id/JURITEXT000031374097/
The parent correctly warned for the article’s bias, I confirm the author is cherrypicking little parts and blow them up for dramatic effect.