They didn't all agree, though. Now there's Ethereum (the people who agreed with the fork) and Ethereum Classic (the people who didn't agree).
They didn't all agree, though. Now there's Ethereum (the people who agreed with the fork) and Ethereum Classic (the people who didn't agree).
Your first comment [1]
> As long as everyone agrees i see absolutely no problem
and now
> Some agreed, others didn't...Consensus doesn't require everyone to agree, just the majority
So you literally just said there is a problem.
The DAO was a very extraordinary event that occurred under very unique and unrepeatable circumstances.
1. Ethereum had just launched. There was a sense of everything being in beta.
2. The Ethereum stakeholder set was very small, so obtaining consensus for such a controversial hard fork was much easier to accomplish than it would be today.
3. The economy on Ethereum was very small, so
a) a hard fork was far less disruptive than it would be today.
b) an undermining of Ethereum's commitment to neutrality/immutability jeapardized far fewer decentralized application projects than it would today.
4. Smart contracts were completely new, so there was a sense that people could be forgiven for their mistakes.
5. The Ethereum Foundation had promoted the idea of a DAO on their website, and several Ethereum founders had promoted the specific DAO that ended up being hacked. These facts made the DAO appear to be more than a completely third party app.
Ethereum is very different today than it was in 2016, and a DAO-scale mishap would never lead to a hard fork again.