How Amazon, Google and Other Companies Exploit NDAs
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
When you leave a company, they typically pay you something to sign it.
How did this work in this case?
It's incredible to me that NDAs with government officials are allowed. They should not be.
The transition was fairly smooth, but the megacorporation wanted us to sign NDAs, which most of the engineers did, but I made the mistake of actually reading it, and realizing that they kind of stuck an extremely vague non-compete in there. I didn't sign it.
I was at that company for a whole year longer, every week getting a "reminder" email to sign the NDA, which I never did.
I'm not a jerk, I didn't disclose any company secrets or release their code, but I doubt I was the only person who found that little "we don't feel like firing you" loophole, and the others might have been a little less nice than me.
So really I think the focus should be more on forcing politicians to be more open with their actions and for this to have the force of law. Then the NDAs become irrelevant. Of course this is an uphill battle since the laws probably need to be passed by the very people who are running the system, but I don't really see how that's avoidable outside of jurisdictions with forms of direct citizen initiatives.
You can do it by having lower costs in total. We just should incentivize market forces to work at the land/labor level and not bring taxes into it.
It also gives an advantage to larger players who can negotiate these deals, and the little guy is left in the cold.
Obviously the answer to the question of "do tax breaks generate jobs/stimulate economic development" is very context sensitive; policies that work in San Francisco may be wholly unsuitable for NYC or Topeka, Kansas or what have you. But there is an overall consensus of data as to what generates good outcomes for towns/states and what doesn't in terms of job creation and economic development:
- Corporate tax breaks, by and large, do NOT generate more economic development for the cities/states that offer them and produce the smallest gains in job creation than any other option. They do however generate more wealth for that particular company.
- Income tax breaks for lower and middle class income earners are more effective at stimulating growth and produce more jobs.
- Strong unemployment benefits stimulate the most growth and economic activity and the most job creation by a very long shot.
The linked reports provide many citations for the points it makes. It's conclusions also align with everything we've been hearing and seeing for the past 20 years with our own eyes in the USA. I liked the observation made in the report that 3M, based out of Minnesota, saw corporate tax cuts offered to them by competing states wreaked of desperation in their minds, not business opportunity. Very intriguing food for thought. I have to say, chances are low that any other company would see this any differently. Its just that companies such as Amazon thrive on the economic desperation of their workers as evidenced by Amazon's own behavior.
On that last bullet point, I'm willing to bet the current "boom" in economic activity is due in large part to the generous unemployment benefits that COVID has forced our government into the past year. The current mobility of many workers I think can be attributed to this, thus stimulating job creation and more competitiveness for companies to make better job offerings. We've seen how companies have behaved in this environment -- lots of layoffs, furloughs and outright job cuts.
Mind you, I don't think all companies are evil or some such. Rather, business incentives in the USA are rarely aligned with the economic benefits of the places they ply their trades/services.
[0] https://www.thebalance.com/do-tax-cuts-create-jobs-3306325
See also: "Revenues from hot dogs and ticket sales means the sports stadium that we've so handsomely subsidized will pay for itself in a couple of years."
There’s another loser: the companies/entrepreneurs that do not get these tax benefits and are disadvantaged in the market.
A thought experiment: let's suppose that the corporate tax in your state is exactly 0%. A corporation still employs a lot of people in your state, and these people pay taxes. Having them unemployed or working at jobs that paid less would be a loss for the state tax income.
Am I missing something?
The entire concept of being able to sign your fundamental human rights away is a bit nuts to me. It's as if it were legal to sign up to get murdered.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/1905
They usually do not sign NDAs (and can get in trouble if they do, especially if it interferes with their offical duties).
If the code does not do that, it should be amended.
Oh wait... there is (at least in the UK - not so sure about the US but I imagine there are similar laws there). Hmm.
Even while logged in and using a subscription access code from my local library.
[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/40122067-the-billionaire...
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/bypass-paywal...
https://gitlab.com/magnolia1234/bypass-paywalls-firefox-clea...
>Congress shall make no law [...] abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press
NDA isn't a law made by congress, so it's fine.
States charter corporations.
Ergo, elected officials at any level may void corporate NDAs at will.
(then again, something along those lines is my solution to most problems involving corporations....)
When I worked at a state government agency, we would laugh at companies with these things as freedom of information and other laws have precedence over some NDA.
Texas is a weird place, but usually these laws are pretty similar between states. These economic development agencies are making a conscious decision to make this information privileged. I wouldn’t blame the companies for this at all — the government entities are the ones enabling this.