New patent troll Kootol emerges
macworld.com
macworld.com
Craig wrote the much linked to article about the fall of the independent developer yesterday: http://furbo.org/2011/07/13/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-indepen...
and today has been tweeting about how he feels like his ability to control his own products has been taken from him:
http://twitter.com/#!/chockenberry/status/91904807748640770 http://twitter.com/#!/chockenberry/status/91905256870510593 http://twitter.com/#!/chockenberry/status/91940943183347712 http://twitter.com/#!/chockenberry/status/91972743561613312
It is depressing. And enraging.
If you get a notice from them, you can just toss it in the trash. They cannot sue you over a patent application.
Furthermore, their application was filed on 2010-12-20, so even if the patent issues nothing that was in use in public before 2009-12-20 can infringe.
Whole year worth of time travel -- i.e., of retroactive monopoly?
So, we can divide potential prior art into two groups:
1. Publications or products from 2009-12-20. Definitely prior art, even if Kootol actually was the inventor of the technology and invented it before the prior art. Too bad for them--they shouldn't have waited so long to file.
2. Publications or products from 2009-21-21 through the filing date. Not prior art. (That doesn't mean others using the technology in this period might not be useful against Kootol--it could be useful for showing that they were not the first to invent the relevant technology).
1. Only remake software that has obvious prior art you can refer to, preferably if the software being replicated is past the age of patent expiration.
2. Release anything that might infringe as open source, with a patent protection license clause (Apache, etc.), using a pseudonym to avoid being targeted.
3. Move to a location outside of legal jurisdiction, and use business trickery to operate in countries. Have fun setting up shell companies and other ways to frustrate litigants.
One can only laugh. They founded an entire company on a patent put together by looking at what people are currently doing, and noticing that there isn't a patent for it yet.
I can't wait to see how hard this one gets smashed into the ground!
Good luck with that.
Living in the EU, I'm not quite clear on some of the legal aspects - can't defendants represent themselves in court in the US? It would be a pleasantly unbalanced situation: nominal legal fees on the individual's side, but many magnitudes higher on the opposing party's.
Imagine a legal wiki, with shared experiences and legal knowledge... Why not use our common smarts and networking savvy to take on this biggest of threats to the independent developer?
This does not mean that Kootol is not a patent troll or that this is a legitimate invention. I don't know what the claims in 878/MUM/2005 are, and its title reads completely insane in American English ("connecting brains to equally like brains?"). Kootol has filed for several other, similar patents[2] that cite 878/MUM/2005. I wonder if 878/MUM/2005 really backs all of these different claims, or if it is simply a vague-enough tool for them to be using to make new claims that can be applied retroactively?
For smaller (i.e. one-person) companies targeted by this kind of insanity, would it make sense to dissolve the corporation being targeted and simply transfer ownership of the targeted product to a new business entity instead of even bothering with investigative legal costs?