European countries tax middle class people to subsidize the 25-30% of relatively privileged people who get a university degree. That’s actually quite regressive. The Anglo (US, UK, and AUS) system of government loans with income-based repayment is superior.
There are a lot of progressive spending proposals and they all can't be paid by just taxing the wealthy.
Using that money to pay for benefits that mostly go to privileged people is not the best use of dollars. College graduates make more money on average, by a lot, 30 thousand dollars.
Our current system address those who have loans but don't actually get high income. They barely have to pay their loans--and often don't pay anything. A person making 35k, with an average of 3.5% a year income growth won't pay a single cent under the PAYE program if they have a family of four.
So, any particular change to our current system of taxation might be flawed. However, in general, we must change our current system of taxation.
https://www.newsweek.com/warren-buffett-who-advocates-higher...
The fact of the matter is that if you define “wealthy” as the top 1% (as Biden implicitly does by refusing to raise taxes on folks making up to $400,000), then there just isn’t enough money there to pay for a robust welfare state without raising middle class and upper middle class taxes. Doubling the tax rate on the top 1% (which isn’t in the cards) would raise $650 billion annually. That won’t even come close to closing the current budget deficit, and won’t pay for even a third of Medicare for all. It would pay for the Biden infrastructure plan, plus maybe free college, but none of the other things in the progressive wish list.
Even if we take as drastic a step as doubling the tax rate on the top 1%, it would still be highly inequitable to distribute that money for free college before hitting priorities like universal healthcare, improved unemployment insurance, etc.
Leaving education loans solely to the private sector (with regulations against predatory marketing and usury) would ensure the money is spent efficiently. It wouldn't be possible to get a large loan for a degree with dim economic prospects. Colleges would need to look at their cost structures and charge students according to the actual market value of the degree.
The European model at least has costs under control. The people who get university degrees presumably also contribute more to the tax base, once they start working, than people without degrees. So it's less regressive than it seems.
It’s best to think of the US public sector as comparable to that of a semi-functioning developed country, such as Italy, rather than one of the competent ones, like Germany or Sweden.
It's been deliberately sabotaged to be this way. We can easily make different choices.
https://www.cbpp.org/research/state-budget-and-tax/a-lost-de...
>States provide roughly 53 percent of the costs of teaching and instruction at these schools. Schools have made up the difference with tuition increases, cuts to educational or other services, or both.
>These sharp tuition increases have accelerated longer-term trends of college becoming less affordable and costs shifting from states to students.
We spend so much because we refuse to fund things directly. By shifting costs onto students, prices go up for everyone. Then aid to students has to be increased, creating this cycle. If we fund higher educational institutions directly, we can reduce costs for everyone.
>Over the past several years, public colleges and universities have cut faculty positions, eliminated course offerings, closed campuses, and reduced student services, among other cuts.
The idea of relentlessly "trimming the fat" has eliminated all slack capacity in our society and economy, to our detriment. Ask anyone who incompletely copied the lean Toyota model and didn't allow for a stockpile or excess capacity where it was prudent to do so. We're delaying infrastructure projects that will only get more expensive to fix. We can't keep pushing these problems into the future and hoping we'll stumble upon a magic solution later. We're at the point where we need to make drastic changes because we've been collectively refusing to make incremental changes.
We are an incredibly wealthy society. We can afford education and healthcare (very similar causes, very similar solutions) for everyone in the USA and we merely need to make the choices to do so.