Software with telemetry is spyware.
Software with telemetry is spyware.
I'm OK with telemetry as long as it's not a communications platform and doesn't forward any work (e.g. code, audio files) I do with it. Telemitry like what buttons or keyboard shortcuts I use, summarized into statistics are fine.
I'm not OK with spyware.
Muse Group could have laid down very specific ground rules: telemetry will always be opt-in, you'll be able to audit exactly what is sent, it will never contain low-level keystroke information, it will be anonymized before being saved into our database and be impossible to associate with a cloud user login. That would be the opposite of spyware! But they didn't set these ground rules, and now they have this entire uprising on their hands. I'd like to give them the opportunity to do right and learn from this experience. But they also need a wake-up call that they need to work to earn back the community's trust.
That is spyware. How I use an application should not be anyone's business. It's a hop-skip-and-a-jump to learn private information from how software is used.
For example: do you hover your mouse over an icon? Do you let it linger for a unique amount of time? Do you have a particular writing style? Do you have a particular time between each keystroke? When you crash the application do you just re-open it or go do something different? Do you exit the application cleanly or do you power off the computer? Do you use the application without a license? Does your computer clock magically change? Does your computer location move? Do you travel between cities a lot, or even countries? Do you interact with the application in one location but leave it in the background in another location? Do you talk while the application is in use? Do your eyes follow your cursor? Are your eyes looking at the application while you're using it? Do you talk about other products while using the application?
ALL of this is private information. Telemetry is just a hop-skip-and-a-jump to data mining.
I strongly disagree. The frequency with which I use my mouse to click buttons vs. keyboard shortcuts to invoke functionality in a program is not personal information, and a system that collects it is not spyware.
> For example: do you hover your mouse over an icon?
This is not private information. In fact, about half of the things you indicated are clearly not. What you're describing are points of data collection that could be used for fingerprinting, which is an entirely separate issue, and can be defeated relatively easily (by adding noise, not recording some pieces of data, and aggregating others).
> Does your computer location move? Do you travel between cities a lot, or even countries?
The other half of the things that you describe are actual spying and wouldn't be called telemetry anyway. This is a strawman argument.
> It's a hop-skip-and-a-jump to learn private information from how software is used.
Tell me how the Audacity developers knowing that I press a sequence of three buttons in a row enables them to determine that I'm single, or how tall I am, or that I like Polish TV dramas, or literally any other personal information?
This is an absurd fallacy. Even assuming that the developers somehow managed to sneak in granular enough telemetry (ignoring real keyloggers, because again, we're talking about telemetry) that they could fingerprint you, literally the only thing that allows them to do is identify when a the same person uses Audacity on multiple machines. There's no leakage of actual personal information.
You appear to be setting up a straw-man argument of what "telemetry" is, and then knocking it down again. Let me state it explicitly: "telemetry" does not include any personal data. Programs that collect "telemetry" that includes personal data are lying - and that has nothing to do with an actual argument about telemetry.
Most users are simply incapable of understanding how the data can be used. They cannot agree to something they do not understand. What users do and how is being stolen and used for purposes that they do not agree to.
The definition of private information is anything and everything that the user does. It's not a "data leak". It's straight up theft. Telemetry, by definition, is a theft of private information.
This is absolutely absurd and completely false. It is not private information that I am running a copy of Audacity or Firefox or Emacs (quite the opposite, I want people to know that I use the superior text editor), and neither does the same statement apply in real life - "anything and everything a human does IRL is private" is a similarly obviously false statement.
> Telemetry, by definition, is a theft of private information.
Again, false, because telemetry is defined as non-private data. Neither, in fact, does "telemetry" imply non-consent - you can have opt-out or opt-in telemetry, and either one can have a prompt that is shown to the user on program start-up.
No, it is neither absurd nor false.
> It is not private information that I am running a copy of Audacity or Firefox or Emacs (quite the opposite, I want people to know that I use the superior text editor)
That's your choice. But your choice should not be imposed upon others.
Not everyone wants others to know what software they use. I don't want others to know whether I use Audacity or WinAmp or Clementine or VLC or Firefox or Chrome or Vivaldi or Opera or Emacs or vi or vim or TextEdit unless I specifically choose to tell them so.
> and neither does the same statement apply in real life - "anything and everything a human does IRL is private" is a similarly obviously false statement.
I didn't say anything and everything IRL.
If you're in your own home then everything you do in your home should be private. Likewise when I'm using my own computer then everything I do in that computer should also be private.
Alright, because you don't seem interested in making an argument about this, and merely responding with a "no": provide a commonly-accepted definition for "private information" that fully substantiates your claim.
> That's your choice. But your choice should not be imposed upon others.
Nobody's choice is being imposed upon anybody? I never said that people shouldn't be able to opt-out, and I don't believe that, either.
> I don't want others to know whether I use Audacity or WinAmp or Clementine or VLC or Firefox or Chrome or Vivaldi or Opera or Emacs or vi or vim or TextEdit unless I specifically choose to tell them so.
This is a fallacy - not all of these programs have telemetry.
> I didn't say anything and everything IRL.
That's the real-life equivalent to your unfounded claim about the digital world.
> If you're in your own home then everything you do in your home should be private. Likewise when I'm using my own computer then everything I do in that computer should also be private.
I reject both your analogy, and your claim that things that you do on your computer are always "private" without further qualification. Instead, I ask you to tell me: what is the possible harm that can come from the Audacity developers (not the world in general) knowing that someone, somewhere is using Audacity, and what buttons they're clicking?
You need to improve your reading comprehension.
> provide a commonly-accepted definition for "private information" that fully substantiates your claim
I've already provided a definition of private information. You're rejecting it.
> I never said that people shouldn't be able to opt-out, and I don't believe that, either.
People shouldn't need to opt-out. People should need to opt-in if they want it. Opted-out should be the default state.
> This is a fallacy - not all of these programs have telemetry.
No of course not because some programs actually respect users' privacy.
> what is the possible harm that can come from the Audacity developers (not the world in general) knowing that someone, somewhere is using Audacity, and what buttons they're clicking?
What buttons do you press? There's no harm in telling me. Do you use my music app? If I change the EULA on the app and then send an update to you, what data can I steal from your computer? Can I steal your bank account information? When are you asleep? Can I find out when the best time would be to port your phone number? When are you most likely to be at work and nowhere near home so that I can muck around your home computer without you bothering?
What possible harm can come from Audacity developers holding private information? Clearly nothing at all. NO harm could ever ever come from knowing what software people use, or how they use it. Nope. Notta. Zip. Zilch. It's not harmful in any way. Speaking of which, what buttons do you press to unlock your phone?
It absolutely can be uniquely tied to you. Whether or not it is personal information doesn't matter: it is still spyware.
> This is not private information.
Yes it is. What I do on my own computer is absolutely private information.
> Tell me how the Audacity developers knowing that I press a sequence of three buttons in a row enables them to determine that I'm single, or how tall I am, or that I like Polish TV dramas, or literally any other personal information?
It's not just three buttons in a row. It's every button over the lifetime of the installation. It's uniquely what buttons you press, where, how long you might hold the mouse button down, what songs you listen to, in what order, did you double-click them or drag them to a playlist or go through a menu; do you set a playlist and forget it or do you interact with the playlist often?
Just because you are unable to see how to do it doesn't mean that it can't be done.
It is unquestionably spyware. Any data which leaves my computer without my approval, is spyware.
As others have noted, 20 years ago this was not even remotely a question. Any application sending any data at all that wasn't directly part of its functionality would spark outrage.
It is sad that somehow spyware has become normalized in some circles. It's never ok.
"In software, telemetry is used to gather data on the use and performance of applications and application components, e.g. how often certain features are used, measurements of start-up time and processing time, hardware, application crashes, and general usage statistics and/or user behavior. In some cases, very detailed data is reported like individual window metrics, counts of used features, and individual function timings." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telemetry
I would encourage you to re-read my post, if that is how you took it.
I was. I had a rude version in mind, believe me. My post is very short and the sentence-diagrams not particularly complex, as far as I can tell.
[EDIT] frankly, the "nicer" ways I could think of to say it all felt passive-aggressive as hell no matter how carefully worded, so I stuck with simple and direct. Re-reading the post was apt, respectful advice.
Could the entire OS be considered spyware? Should Win 11, which is expected to have mandatory MSFT account, be considered something worse than spyware?