It's much like E-bay: everybody knows they suck, everyone wants a competitor, but the network effects are so huge that a frontal assault is doomed to fail.
http://www.imdb.com/interfaces
It probably wouldn't be a good idea, without massive amounts of resources (i.e Jason-Calacanis-mahalo-style), to try to recreate the data. Creating mashups with their data seems more reasonable. But can you build a startup out of it?
EDIT: And I do not think you need better content in the beginning. A better UI will do.
http://www.google.ca/movies/reviews?cid=b1bbc12bd62930eb&...
Anything specific you're really dying for?
What are most people using these days? Steve Jobs showed "rotten tomatoes" in his iTunes-Video presentation, maybe that is where everybody is heading these days?