This is one of the primary reasons I'm a pure libertarian. The more in depth research I did, the more I found it's nothing but a rigged game.
It truly is like the joke that's along the lines of:
"What's the difference between the government and the mob?"
"The mob didn't get 12,000 hours of schooling to convince you it's necessary."
I think libertarianism is quite self-contradictory, because if we assume completely fair starting conditions (they historically never were) and assume that people are renumerated fairly (which is subjective and disputable), the system as a whole tends to accumulate wealth in hands of smaller and smaller number of citizens, if nothing else then by just random chance, and since the property ownership is sacrosanct, there is no mechanism which could counteract the accumulation. Then these people might use the accumulated wealth to oppress others, as a kind of oligopoly. This contradiction was actually pointed out by Marx, who predicted that end of capitalism (a revolution) will come out as a result of this process.
But concentration to this degree practically requires government force to survive. I believe even those on your side of the political spectrum believe that corruption is what prevents the people from properly benefiting from government intervention.
I believe both you and I want us to stop (or never have started) all the wars of the past 20 years. This is a very popular viewpoint, yet moneyed interests prevent this.
I believe you and I have like ideals, but I don't believe deference to authority can ever bring them about. Authority always ends up corrupt.
> This contradiction was actually pointed out by Marx, who predicted that end of capitalism (a revolution) will come out as a result of this process.
And yet the Soviet Union is the system that fell.
Let's not rewrite history here. All of the American wars of the last few decades where very popular with (most) American voters when then they started.
There's no doubt the American military-industrial complex had some role in manufacturing consent, but don't kid yourself into thinking that the will of the American voters wasn't critical to the political strategy of the government.
Presumably, there would be government (or equivalent force) to enforce the private property rights? So I am not sure how that addresses the problem I outlined. And how do you make sure this force doesn't become corrupt?
> I don't believe deference to authority can ever bring them about. Authority always ends up corrupt.
Here's the thing. I believe there is a third option that is outside the "capitalist" spectrum which I am talking about (the liberal society of freely trading men who each have plot of land vs authoritarian society of landed gentry as a result of capital accumulation).
And that 3rd option is keeping wealth within certain limits by democratic control, through for example progressive taxes on either income or wealth, and redistribution of this to people who lost all (or most of) property, or just everybody in equal manner. Like a basic income that would be financed by the richest. See, this solution is different from both ends of the spectrum, and sidesteps the authoritarian problem (there is no decision to be made about where the money are going, there is a simple rule how they are redistributed, and this rule is agreed by consensus). The government that in libertarianism has to exist to enforce property rights could as well enforce this redistribution.
How 'pure' is pure libertarian? Do we allow private currencies to be issues by anyone, this used to be a massive problem?
Does someone in 'pure libertatian' society get a free defence attorney or school education? Do we have fire safety laws? We used to have entire cities burn down.
Do we regulate banks and financial markets at all? Do we have a regulator to stop ponzi schemes if the contract explains the mechanisms in fine print?
It feels like there would be a tidal wave of financial machinations where ordinary people would loose their shirts.
> We used to have entire cities burn down.
https://mises.org/library/development-municipal-fire-departm...
This same resource hits nearly every one of your points with well reasoned alternatives to government intervention.
Instead of expecting an answer to every what if that immediately comes to mind, please research the viewpoint from credible libertarian sources like the Mises Institute.
Another research avenue--anything Murray Rothbard.
Government is monopoly of violence.
For example, mono crop wheat is terrible, but the government uses its monopoly of force to coerce me into subsidies for foods I refuse to eat.
These subsidies are the reason it's healthiest to stick to the perimeter of the store. Without them, cheap cereal junk foods would at least not be so cheap.
This encouragement of low quality mono cropping directly supports big ag and companies like Monsanto. I'd much rather spend my money at a local farm.
These organizations are either government sanctioned or considered criminal.
The libertarian viewpoint on this is that all initiation of force is criminal.
> if you support a minimal government that enforces private property rights
I don't support that. I think individuals should take the protection of themselves and their property seriously. And no, I don't just mean having a gun, but instead seeking a place that honors private property and or paying for protection services as needed. Everything the government provides, a private entity can as well.
What count as initiation of force? If I walk into your house and take your things, am I initiating use of force? If I want to live somewhere where that is not the norm, how am I supposed to find that place? It seems very idealistic to me that such a place could exist without it being enforced somehow.
> instead seeking a place that honors private property and or paying for protection services as needed. Everything the government provides, a private entity can as well.
If that private entity makes that provision through the use of force, do they not then constitute a government of sorts? If they do not use force, then how do they manage to make that provision at all?
I can't wait untill we have two different "protection services" come into conflict because they are "protecting" different things and we have shootouts on the streets.
Much like the latest incident with Vigilante app, but imagine both entities had good for hire
https://www.theverge.com/2021/5/21/22447446/citizen-app-inte...
This us mental gymnastics.
Oh, customer's chose a network operator that sells their data. Nevermind that all 4 network operators sell your data! Or could have chosen to live without a phone and be like a hermit in the woods!
It's always in the interest of insurance companies to pay out as little as they can get away with.