This approach reminds me a bit of the saying in neuroscience "if it fires together, it wires together"
This approach reminds me a bit of the saying in neuroscience "if it fires together, it wires together"
Though there is one important bit of asymmetry: you connect to those who upvoted that item *before* you. That way people who recognize useful information earlier earn more trust. In a sense this is a "proof of work" - to recognize valuable content before it becomes popular.
My hope is that this asymmetrical nature of connections will get less informed people to connect to more informed people. Which is the opposite of the echo-chamber effect - when less informed people are connected to similarly less informed peers.
And yes, I'm slowly preparing to do a "Show NH" for LinkLonk. But I probably need to grow the number of active users a bit before I do that, otherwise the "Shown HN" will bring a lot of clicks that will just bounce.
You have to be good at prediction what people will like in order to get them connected to you. And this is what a good curator does.
As in, will this dynamic tend to reward the spread of "edgy" fake news more than current network paradigms already do, or will it tend to slow its spread, or will it be neutral on that axis? Seems like a hypothesis that would need to be tested, but maybe you have a hunch or insight on the matter.
But as a user I can say that I do behave differently when it comes to upvoting content on LinkLonk. It is much less impulsive because my ratings have consequences for myself. If I find something that I completely agree with but I haven't learned anything new - I would not upvote it on LinkLonk, while I would be tempted to signal boost it elsewhere (like HN). Let's see whether this generalizes and what kind of system behaviour emerges out of it.
To properly test it out we need more users.