Defender was head and shoulders above every other arcade game when it was released. It consumed quite a bit of my pocket money.
I never managed to really gel with it, probably because of the control scheme. But I always respected how it was SO unapologetically hardcore -- it was a game for the true arcade masters.
I wasn't a total wimp at least. My favorite game from the era is probably Robotron, also by Jarvis. Absolutely punishingly hard as well. Love it to this day.
Raw is probably the most resonant descriptor to me.
I got a chance to play on a real machine a while back.
I am a lot older, worse, but better than laggy play would suggest. Timing matters. A low latency experience is best for this game.