U.S. Surgeon General's Misinformation Advisory [pdf]
hhs.gov
hhs.gov
My concern is what about when experts are wrong? Like when the surgeon general tweeted last year, "STOP BUYING MASKS! They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus, but if healthcare providers can’t get them to care for sick patients, it puts them and our communities at risk!"
Just because an expert was wrong once doesn't mean it's suddenly impossible to differentiate between experts and misinformation.
"Misinformation" is the new code word for wrong-think. It's none of their business what "incorrect" information people may or may not choose to consume. It's the people that decide.
Saying that the Earth is not flat, or that the Earth revolves around the Sun used to considered "misinformation" too.
Nothing just snaps into existence with full consensus of everyone. They start as "misinformation" by people who are ahead of the curve, and slowly gain mainstream attention and acceptance (e.g. "Lab leak theory" used to be "misinformation and disinformation" and people got suspended for mentioning it ... now the loudspeakers talk about it too).
No it's not. It's saying that this stuff has a lot of nuance and you aren't going to have a rule to classify it.
Sorry, that's just how the world and its laws and policies have worked for centuries. You aren't making a point by saying "it's impossible to 100% differentiate an expert being wrong from misinformation."
And that's why we created the first amendment, because we found out how bad of an idea is for gov's to censor.
How well do you think this is going to go over with the moderates and the right? The only reason you're supporting this atm is because it supports your side's group think.
Parent poster is right, in normal discussion you'll have disagreements. Only one side is calling it misinformation.