Antirez on GitHub CoPilot
twitter.com
twitter.com
I've used Copilot for the past couple of weeks and haven't found this to be the case.
Most of the time Copilot doesn't really understand what I'm doing or isn't useful because I'm doing exploratory programming. For the trivial stuff, I've found that it's easier to write it myself because then I don't have to correct what an AI is thinking so it fits into the project or compiles.
I'm a big fan of Copilot. I think the outrage is overblown. But it hasn't been useful enough to prove that most programming is "devoid of creativity and repetitive".
> "Every task Copilot can do for you is a task that should NOT be part of modern programming, and a signal that our industry is broken and that programmers are the new blue collars."
I really don't get this point. The point of programming and explicitness is control over what gets run.
Are you sick of writing API calls to a weather service? Use no-code or a library. Are you sick of writing an algorithm for X? Find a library for it, there's likely tons, and if there isn't, that's creative work for ya. Dislike setting up a React project? Use a boilerplate. Sick of plumbing things together? Try no-code.
Feeling like nothing you're making is creative? Go write your own OS or something.
This thread reeks of the whole elitist "programming used to be real work back then" attitude.
Just as welding can be done for art or hobbyist endeavors, there’s a whole lot of welding that is boring, repetitive, and/or devoid of anything fun or creative. But that work still needs to be done. I’m not a software engineer, but if you can pull junior and mid level engineers up using software and machine learning, why wouldn’t you? Automate All The Things.
Following that line… > programmers are the new blue collars.
Yes, very much. If “you” want to make a living creating art then godspeed, and I may even appreciate your creation. But solving problems through efficient production takes a very different skillset, tools, and organization. And companies employ developers to solve problems, not create art.
> I'm a big fan of Copilot.
Wow, big whiplash reading that. Your review makes it sound useless and obtrusive. Are you a masochist, or does it have some redeeming qualities you neglected to mention?
One can find something imperfect yet simultaneously believe strongly in it.
The era of rapid technological progress has led to the fetishization of novelty. It is new, therefore it must be much better that what came before. That era has ended somewhere in the late XX century, possibly in the '70s. The technological landscape hasn't changed much since with the notable exception of mobile computing. Time to grow up.
Edit. Something that blows my mind. From 1900 by 1970 (70 years) the world moved from flight being a remote dream to Boeing 747. From 1970 to 2020 (next 50 years), hundreds of 747 are still on active duty, and the successor 777 is merely marginally more efficient.