The Race For Lock-in: Google+ and Facebook
blog.ingenic.com
blog.ingenic.com
Argh, how does Google have lock-in with search? The minute Google stops delivering relevant results, you can switch search engines with practically no cost.
That's the thing. Amazon has a better product search, IMDB has better movie search, and StackOverflow has better results for technical question. Google doesn't necessarily provide the best results for all queries, but people still use it because it's easy, even though it's not the best.
In that way, Google has lock-in with search.
I can actually get my web history on Google, Google provides an XML feed of searches I could take and give to someone else if I wanted to -- but it only covers a 1 month snapshot. It has the term I searched for, and the link I clicked on. That is a pretty good corpus of information about me. Google could provide all of my web history, that would be a very positive sign of non lock-in behavior. Maybe they do somewhere, but I don't see it on the DLF page. So I agree with you that they could do more.
But I disagree with your apparent reasoning as to what lock-in actually means.
Take their two most successful non-search products, Android and Chrome. Both of these are Open Source, and are explicitly positioned not directly to make money for Google, but rather to offer a highly functional, feature-rich and free product so that nobody else in the same market can try and lock consumers into their product without looking lacklustre by comparison.
Thus far Chrome has been extremely successful in this regard, Android moderately so - but that's Google's modus operandi throughout their business, and there's no reason to suspect that Plus will be anything different.
They just want to make sure they can search it - they don't care who controls it.