Israel Wants US States to Enforce Anti-BDS Laws Against Ben and Jerry’s
news.antiwar.com
news.antiwar.com
There is nothing either fundamentally anti-semitic or even anti-Zionist to disagreeing with the way Israel operates either diplomatically abroad or in terms of domestic politics. About the only anti-anything at play is anti-occupying-things-that-aren't-yours-on-paper-the international-community-agrees-on-and-expecting-everyone-else-to-cut-you-a-sweetheart-deal-to-help-you-hold-it-whilst-treating-those-who-lived-there-already-as-garbage-while-demanding-everyone-else-buys-into-your-rationalizatio ns-to-avoid-coming-to-a-peaceful-compromise-on-threat-of-being-branded-an-anti-semite.
Anti-semitic? Nope. Nothing there against the Jewish faith. Anti-Zionist? Nope. Have your State, just don't ignore or marginalize indigenous populations there at the same time. I don't care if everyone else has done it in the past , that doesn't make it okay to do now.
That doesn't really fit in a snazzy headline though, one, and number two, anti-BDS laws are exactly the kind of foreign entanglements George Washington cautioned against.
There's practically no way to engage in it without engaging with anti-semitic elements. You have to ask yourself why you're engaging it at all, rather than any of thousands of other ethnic conflicts you could be picking. To come up with an answer, you have to engage the whole question -- which also means dealing with the inherent anti-semitism.
I need to make abundantly clear that none of this is intended to excuse any of the abuses the Israeli government is engaging. Just because the well is poisoned doesn't mean that there aren't genuine atrocities being committed, and that they may well merit sanctions.
But it really figures into your very last assertion: the best reason to avoid foreign entanglements is that you probably don't understand them. And picking some subset of foreign entanglements will always leave you open to incoherent actions, especially when you've picked that subset for reasons you never fully understood in the first place.