If you agree agree with the GP that people should be paid based on their negotiating skills, then you also support paying people regardless of their performance. Those are two mutually exclusive criteria.
Nah, it's finer grained than that. Negotiating skills are the cherry on top, but they are dependent on performance.
You can't negotiate if you don't have offer a level of performance that justifies the negotiation.
You won't even get the interview (and therefore opportunity to negotiate) without the "performance" i.e. actual work related skills.
Participating in interview *: 0 or 1
Participating in negotiation for a higher income: 0 or 1
* Note: An interview is only obtained based on past performance (that is, a person previously performed work at a certain level).