It also use to be true! The main thing that changed is government policies increasingly restricting supply.
It also use to be true! The main thing that changed is government policies increasingly restricting supply.
Big cities obviously have economies of scale, so, say, the chicken lo mein is fresher and hotter due to higher volume. Or, the first time I had a cup of plain coffee at a random cafe in NYC, it was stunningly good. Any reasonably successful business has much higher volume than in a less populated area and is pressured by competition more too. They can and must do better.
But people make more money on average in a big city, and that means they spend more. If the exact grade of hamburger available everywhere is 20% cheaper, that doesn't in any way prevent your meals from being much more expensive. The whole point of being in a city is so you can get stuff you can't otherwise.
If you are living and working in NYC, are you going to just have the same fast food you could get in Albany, that's incrementally better?
Don't mix up "city dwellers use less resources for a unit of a given thing" with "city dwellers use less resources period".
True rural and true urban (with public transit predominating) is good. But the suburbs where most people live are absolute trash.
I'm inclined to think that carbon emissions (or consumption in general) are primarily a product of wealth.
It would be possible in principle to normalize that map for household income, and I wonder if it would show the same pattern.
We don't need to go to extremes (a Parisian studio can go as low as 100 square feet!) but house size in the US has mostly crept up as a function of minimum lot sizes in US zoning.
People in the US have a choice between the two, and they’re largely chosen to put up with a commute from the suburbs in exchange for more space. Those lot sizes aren’t just wasted space. Lower density also translates to more green space, lower noise, fewer shared spaces, etc.
This is why it's incredibly important that we fix this stuff. Rich environmentalists' "sacrifices" achieve nothing. It is also why I am incredibly sad the current infrastructure bill is slated to fund so much stupid suburbanization.
If we want revitalized cities where people want to live, we don’t just need low cost housing, we need high value housing. The middle class didn’t leave cities on cost alone and they’re not going to move back to cities on cost alone.
> There are plenty of apartments available in cities at rents lower than the average suburban mortgage payment.
But what is the floor area? Saying people don't need McMansions is not the same as saying additional bedrooms for kids isn't nice.
> If we want revitalized cities where people want to live, we don’t just need low cost housing, we need high value housing.
It's very easy to tear down walls making bigger units. Focusing on the cost of housing is the key part. Value comes after.
Also remember that suburbs and driving is massively subsidize, even separately from the externalizes. It's not fair to expect cities to compete completely on costs without that being fixed.
Go read https://www.strongtowns.org/ for urbanism for small-scale romantics if big cities still sound "just bad".
I think if you focus on cost alone, you’re going to build poor neighborhoods and jump start a cycle of poverty.
I think the key is to build diverse neighborhoods. You want poor, rich, and middle income housing all in the same place. The segregation of incomes is how we got into this mess to begin with.
Other than physical dividers like highways, I don't really think segregation is built?
One big exception is we certainly want the public housing to not be congregated in ghettos. That was another terrible NYCHA (and others) practice.
Zoning is a very recent phenomenon. Cities were economically vibrant long before that. Even if there is zoning it doesn't need to be as exceedingly specific as American zoning tends to be.
It is as if we used to have clumps of matter bound together by gravity, enforced by magic that new matter must be spread out (zoning) but also charged the matter (cars). Merely stopping the magic doesn't meant gravity will overpower electromagnetism.
Zoning and car culture achieved dominance in tandem, and so I am quit skeptical of any certainty that fixing one alone is sufficient to roll back the clock.
There could be other sorts of hystersis too that make this challenging. Really we should be very careful and vigilant and not rely on one tactic to eradicate the scourge of suburbanization.
This is on top how much zoning craziness distorts the market.
I live within city limits, in a multifamily building. But the edge of the city outside of which is presumably "suburban" is literally a few dozen feet away. Also, my neighborhood has a layout and look that I think a lot of people would consider suburban. No businesses, mostly no sidewalks, mostly a cookie cutter development. On the other hand, it's super quick to go from where I live (by car that is) into the middle of the city where I work, which is kind of against the stereotype of suburbs. It's also much cheaper than the "actual" suburbs, probably because it's part of the city school district.
There, did it.
Sounds like your place has some nice benefits, but since you drive everywhere (you mentioned work, and stores not being in the neighborhood, so that's a safe assumption, right?), It's suburban.
I could also technically walk to a convenience store or perhaps a supermarket. It doesn't take that long to walk a mile or two.
Point is though, it's clearly not rural, and it's within a recognized city, so any time people are talking about "urban" it includes this sort of setting. It doesn't matter if you think it should be classified as urban, the fact that it is, means that's where the statistics show up indirectly.
There is a distinct separation in property value between my neighborhood and surrounding suburbs with single-family housing at double or quadruple the price.
Furthermore, as a matter of geometry, any city that is more or less a roundish blob, is going to have more space near the edges than the center. So it seems plausible to me that it's more representative of a city lifestyle. The very center in several cities I've been in is almost completely commercial.
This is the US? I'll happily grant you that the bus system is terrible.
> I could also technically walk to a convenience store or perhaps a supermarket. It doesn't take that long to walk a mile or two.
That's way too far. Don't beat yourself for not walking.
> The fact that it is, means that's where the statistics show up indirectly.
Sure. That's a bummer. Hopefully we can fix that someday.
> Furthermore, as a matter of geometry, any city that is more or less a roundish blob, is going to have more space near the edges than the center. So it seems plausible to me that it's more representative of a city lifestyle. The very center in several cities I've been in is almost completely commercial.
This pattern: (big towers?) commerical monoculture in the center, gradual peetering off, is very (North) American. A lot of other places have stricter transitions at the city boundary, and less division within the city.
That's quite a wide unsubstantiated generalization.
Tons of people have no interest in living in a tiny apartment in a tall building and will happily pay extra to move to the suburbs to avoid that.
The price per square foot is reflective of what the market will pay, first and foremost. The large cost premium in hot cities suggest that the unmet supply of apartment is much larger in percentage terms than the unmet supply of single family housing. In my area rents are already recovered from their COVID slump and still rising.
False. Yes, taller buildings are more expensive per floor. But the benefits they bring in far exceed those costs.
You have to account for the whole system, or track your externalities if it's not closed. And if our current economic systems don't do that, they need to be fixed.
With stores, they’re squeezed on both ends: Pressure from online retailers and then exorbitant rents.
It’s not unusual to have monthly rents that go into mid-five figures for a small store at ground level.
Few small businesses can sustain that in the long term.