Say I have 1 ton of carbon captured, I am paid 1 coin and I "prove" that I captured 1 ton. Secretly, the mechanism of my capture is temporary and I realize not only the 1 ton, but an additional ton as it costed me energy to make this scheme work. What are you gonna do?
Another, more likely example is that I say I have 1 ton captured, EnergyCorp has Bob audit me, I tell Bob, you approve of my fraudulent capture notice and I'll give you 10% of the profits. Bob agrees, I am paid my 1 coin. I give Bob 0.1 of the coin. We both win. Later Bob is found to have participated in the conspiracy. What are you gonna do?
You, the smart reader are reading this and think - OK fine, we'll build a way to confirm capture without anyone else being involved. Well, I point to scenario 1. What're ya gonna do? The post basically assumes trusted auditors, which is fine, but why even do blockchain?
Blockchain cannot beat reality.
For what it's worth, both scenarios apply to traditional fiat, but at least in that scenario punitive damages apply and can be applied. I'm not sure how a tax or fine can or would be applied with any blockchain. It's also not even clear to me why blockchains are even necessary after skimming the OP.