I appreciate your perspective.
I agree about the Thinkpad keyboards. Also, a relative had a Dell 8100 laptop that I used extensively for a while, and its keyboard was very "fast" and comfortable, for me. I think Dell's keyboard quality has gone down since then.
These days, I tend to prefer good laptop keyboards. I like the short throw; also, many of them have a more precise and consistent action than the mass produced detached keyboards.
I'm not familiar enough with the recent Apple keyboards, although I will complain about their (and others') laptop designs of recent years that place the keyboard at the back of a "huge" shelf of real estate often also having a sharp front edge. (Those features bother my wrists no end, particularly when I don't have control over the height of the work surface.)
I've spent time on a variety of stuff going back to DEC terminals (and some yet older stuff I no longer recall). Actually, of older stuff, one of my favorite keyboards was the one that came with my Kaypro. I don't suppose its switches were all that "de luxe", but it was very smooth and I could really move on it without tiring. And/or I was younger ;-) and spent enough time with it specifically to become rather accustomed to its feel.
As for Emacs, every time I start, I quickly tire of its key combination and the discomfort they cause me. I suppose I should try one or another remapping, but I end up switching programs before I get that far. Perhaps if I'd started with it when I was younger, I would have built up a requisite flexibility and muscle memory more rapidly than discomfort.
(As for obsession, I now find the screen and keyboard two of the most important features of a system. It doesn't matter how fast it is, if it's a pain to look at and makes typing an undue exercise.)